14 Jaw-Dropping ‘Then Vs. Now’ Photos of Old Hollywood Heartthrobs That Will Legitimately Make You Feel Ancient

Valerie Bertinelli — Which celebrity/artist was your childhood crush? : r/AskReddit, Photo by pinimg.com, is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0

Alright, let’s be real for a second: who *doesn’t* have a celebrity crush? And who among us hasn’t harbored a secret (or not-so-secret) adoration for the stars who graced our screens during our formative years, or even those who captivated our parents and grandparents? There’s just something about those golden-era idols that sticks with you, a certain sparkle that transcends generations. We’re talking about the kind of charm that makes you wish you had a time machine, even if it’s just for a quick peek!

But here’s the kicker, folks: time marches on for everyone, even for the most dazzling stars of yesteryear. While some of these legendary figures might have faded a bit from the everyday pop culture radar, their impact and undeniable attractiveness are far from forgotten. The internet, ever the nostalgic rabbit hole, recently reminded us of this fact when a Redditor, u/pianoman81, posed a question to the r/GenerationJones community: “Who was the most attractive star that today’s generation doesn’t realize?” And oh boy, did the community deliver!

Hundreds of responses poured in, shining a well-deserved spotlight on former heartthrobs who, frankly, deserve a renewed moment in the sun. From the effortlessly elegant to the irresistibly mischievous, these stars prove that true charisma is ageless, even if their faces have changed a bit over the decades. Get ready for a serious dose of nostalgia, a few swoons, and maybe, just maybe, a tiny existential crisis as we dive into seven of these incredible individuals who will make you want to send a thank-you note to u/pianoman81 for kicking off this delightful trip down memory lane. Seriously, prepare to feel *very, very old* in the best way possible.

1. **Elizabeth Montgomery**Starting off our journey into the glorious past is the utterly enchanting Elizabeth Montgomery, a name that instantly conjures images of twitching noses and magical mischief. For many, she is synonymous with her iconic role as Samantha Stephens on *Bewitched*, a show that captivated audiences and still holds a special place in the hearts of those who remember its original run, or who’ve rediscovered its timeless charm.

It’s clear her appeal was, and still is, powerful. Redditor u/mariposa314 perfectly encapsulates this sentiment, stating, “Yes! I remember loving Bewitched as a kid, so I’ve been revisiting it recently. She is so gorgeous, and her figure is enviable.” And honestly, who could disagree? Montgomery possessed a unique blend of elegance, wit, and a radiant beauty that made her absolutely captivating on screen.

Her graceful demeanor and expressive eyes were just part of her undeniable allure. Beyond the magic, she brought a genuine warmth and intelligence to her roles, making her an enduring figure in television history. Even revisiting her work decades later, her charm is undiminished, reminding us why she was, and remains, a true star.

The fact that her presence still inspires such admiration, even from those revisiting her work years later, speaks volumes. It’s not just nostalgia; it’s a testament to her authentic star power. She truly was one of those rare talents whose beauty was matched by her captivating screen presence, a combination that ensures her legend continues.

“Sir Laurence Olivier: ‘An actor is most successful when not only all his virtues but all his disadvantages come into useful play in a part.’” by British Wallpapers is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 2.0

2. **Sir Laurence Olivier**Next up, we have a legend whose name resonates with theatrical grandeur and cinematic brilliance: Sir Laurence Olivier. While some might first think of his stage work, his film career was equally impactful, cementing his status as one of the greatest actors of all time. His intense charisma and striking good looks translated effortlessly from the stage to the silver screen, captivating audiences across the globe.

Redditor u/SleepsinaTent shared a particularly poignant memory, saying, “He was striking in anything, but I fell in love with him when he was older, when my mom was watching the movie Rebecca on TV.” This comment perfectly illustrates Olivier’s ability to command attention regardless of his age, proving that true magnetism only deepens with time.

His roles were always imbued with a raw intensity and sophisticated depth, making him truly unforgettable. Whether portraying a tormented hero or a complex villain, Olivier had a way of drawing you into his characters, making them feel incredibly real and deeply compelling. His commanding presence was simply undeniable.

Even for those discovering his work years after its initial release, his powerful performances and distinctive features leave a lasting impression. He was more than just handsome; he was a force of nature on screen, a true artist whose impact on acting continues to inspire. It’s no wonder he created crushes that spanned generations.

Eartha Kitt - Batman (1966) — File:Eartha Kitt Catwoman Batman 1967.JPG – Wikimedia Commons, Photo by wikimedia.org, is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0

3. **Eartha Kitt**Oh, Eartha Kitt! Just hearing her name evokes a sense of unparalleled sophistication, sultry charm, and a voice that could melt glaciers. She was an absolute icon, a performer who defied categorization and left an indelible mark on music, stage, and screen. Her unique blend of allure and fierce independence made her an unforgettable presence.

Her captivating power was perfectly summarized by u/uberrob, who simply stated, “Amazing ’til the end.” And truly, she was. Eartha Kitt possessed a timeless elegance and a vibrant energy that never seemed to wane, captivating audiences throughout her extraordinarily long career. Her stage presence was legendary, and her vocal delivery was simply iconic.

From her unforgettable rendition of “Santa Baby” to her powerful acting roles, Kitt always brought an inimitable flair to everything she touched. She was a true original, an artist who was unafraid to be herself and who exuded confidence and charisma in spades. Her beauty was as unconventional as it was breathtaking, a testament to her individuality.

Even in her later years, her magnetism was undimmed, a clear sign of a star whose light burned brightly from start to finish. She embodied a kind of fierce, unyielding glamour that made her truly stand out in any era. Eartha Kitt wasn’t just a star; she was a phenomenon.

4. **Omar Sharif**Prepare for a deep dive into the smoldering gaze of Omar Sharif, a man whose very presence on screen could stop hearts. With his piercing eyes and undeniable charm, Sharif became an international sensation, particularly known for his roles in epic historical dramas that showcased his profound acting talent and striking good looks. He truly was a Hollywood dream boat.

His role in *Dr. Zhivago* is often cited as a pinnacle of his career, a performance that captivated audiences worldwide. It certainly left an impression on u/Pale-Confection-6951’s mother, as they shared, “Omar Sharif in Dr. Zhivago was my mother’s crush. I can see the appeal!” And honestly, who couldn’t? His portrayal of Yuri Zhivago was both sensitive and heroic, making him irresistible.

Sharif had a knack for bringing a quiet intensity and a profound sense of inner life to his characters. He wasn’t just a handsome face; he was a serious actor who could convey a world of emotion with a single glance. His exotic appeal and refined demeanor made him a standout in an era of unforgettable leading men.

Even as he matured, his dignified bearing and captivating eyes remained. He carried himself with an air of classic elegance that made him attractive at every stage of his life. It’s no surprise that his charm transcended generations, proving that some appeals are simply universal.

5. **Angela Lansbury**When you hear the name Angela Lansbury, many immediately think of the sharp-witted Jessica Fletcher from *Murder, She Wrote*. But before she became the beloved amateur sleuth, Lansbury was a versatile actress with a remarkable range and a beauty that was truly striking in her early years. Her career spanned decades, showcasing an incredible evolution as a performer.

Redditor u/TheSilverNail perfectly articulated this generational divide in perception, noting, “Most people only remember Angela Lansbury now from Murder, She Wrote reruns, but she was a stunner in her early years.” It’s a wonderful reminder that stars often have multifaceted careers, and their early work can reveal a different facet of their charm.

In her younger days, Lansbury possessed a glamorous screen presence and a captivating intensity. She tackled diverse roles, from scheming villains to heartfelt ingénues, always delivering performances that were memorable and impactful. Her talent was evident from the very beginning, even if her most famous role came later in life.

Her journey from a dazzling young starlet to a beloved television icon is a testament to her enduring talent and adaptability. It’s always fun to look back and appreciate the full spectrum of a star’s career, especially when it reveals a ‘stunner’ phase that might surprise those only familiar with her later work. She was truly a chameleon of the screen.

6. **Christopher Plummer**Ah, Christopher Plummer! For many, he’ll forever be Captain Georg von Trapp, the dashing and disciplined patriarch from *The Sound of Music*. His portrayal brought a sophisticated charm and a touch of dramatic flair to the role, making him a romantic lead for the ages. He had a way of being both stern and incredibly appealing, a truly unique combination.

It seems his captivating performance in that classic film extended its reach across generations, creating crushes even in grandmothers! As u/professorkarla recounted, “My grandma’s favorite movie was The Sound of Music…because she had a huge crush on Christopher Plummer!” This just goes to show that some leading men possess an undeniable charm that is truly timeless.

Plummer’s distinguished good looks and resonant voice made him a natural fit for period dramas and romantic leads. He carried an air of refined elegance and intelligence in all his roles, whether on screen or stage. His performances were always imbued with a gravitas and an undeniable magnetism that held audiences spellbound.

Even as he aged, Plummer continued to exude a powerful presence and a sharp wit, taking on diverse roles that cemented his legacy as one of the most respected actors of his generation. His enduring appeal is a testament to his talent and the classic charm he brought to every performance. He was a true gentleman of the screen.

7. **Isabella Rossellini**And now, let’s talk about Isabella Rossellini, an icon of beauty, grace, and effortless cool. Daughter of cinematic legends Ingrid Bergman and Roberto Rossellini, she carved out her own remarkable path as an actress and model, captivating the world with her unique, ethereal beauty and down-to-earth personality. She truly embodied a distinct kind of charm.

It’s not just her striking looks, but her genuine nature that draws people to her. Redditor u/lydiatheferret shared a lovely anecdote, saying, “She’s super down-to-earth. I met her at her book signing in Boston years ago, and she was even prettier in person.” This kind of personal touch really highlights her approachable star quality.

Rossellini’s beauty was never just about superficial glamour; it radiated from within, reflecting a thoughtful and intelligent spirit. She graced magazine covers and film screens with a natural elegance that was both alluring and authentic. Her ability to transition seamlessly between high fashion and gritty independent cinema spoke volumes about her versatility.

Her unique blend of vulnerability and strength has made her an enduring figure in the public eye. Even as time passes, her distinct features and captivating persona continue to fascinate and inspire. She represents a kind of timeless beauty that is rooted in character and genuine presence, proving that some stars are simply unforgettable, inside and out.

Alright, buckle up, because we’re not done yet! If you thought the first seven heartthrobs were a wild ride down memory lane, prepare for even more delightful shocks and swoons as we uncover the next batch of incredible stars who absolutely defined attractiveness in their era. Get ready to feel even older (in the best way possible, of course!) as we continue our celebration of timeless charisma.

James Garner — Maverick — James Garner – Store norske leksikon, Photo by snl.no, is licensed under PDM 1.0

8. **James Garner**Oh, James Garner! Just the name conjures up images of a dashing, effortlessly cool leading man with a twinkle in his eye and a charm that could disarm anyone. He was the kind of guy who just exuded a quiet confidence, making him an absolute magnetic force on screen.

Remember his fantastic work alongside Doris Day? Redditor u/ClamsCasino927 perfectly nails his appeal, saying, “My favorite movie of his is The Thrill of It All with Doris Day. It’s in the vein of her pictures with Rock Hudson — mid-century modern, great clothes, a little screwball. It’s delightful, and Mr. Garner is oh-so-attractive.” That really paints a picture, doesn’t it? He just fit that sophisticated, witty, and charming mold so perfectly.

Garner had a knack for making even the most complex characters feel relatable and incredibly likable. Whether he was playing a cowboy or a smooth-talking detective, he brought a genuine warmth and an understated sex appeal that was truly captivating. His performances were always a masterclass in subtlety and charisma.

His enduring appeal lies in that easygoing charm and undeniable handsomeness. He was the quintessential cool guy, the kind you could easily imagine sharing a laugh with or getting swept away by in a romantic comedy. It’s no wonder he remains a beloved figure, a true Old Hollywood crush for the ages.

9. **Yvonne de Carlo**From the moment you see a picture of Yvonne de Carlo, it’s clear she was an absolute force of nature. While many might instantly recognize her as the bewitching Lily Munster, there’s so much more to this star’s incredible story and undeniable allure.

Before she donned the iconic streaks of white in her hair, de Carlo was a bona fide bombshell. As u/GracieThunders put it, she “was a bombshell in a couple of old Westerns, some years before The Munsters.” And honestly, you just have to see her early work to believe it! Her striking features and undeniable screen presence made her a standout in any genre.

She possessed a captivating exotic beauty that set her apart, allowing her to command attention whether she was starring in adventure films, dramas, or, yes, even classic sitcoms. Her ability to transition between such different roles is a testament to her versatility and raw talent.

Yvonne de Carlo’s journey is a fantastic reminder that true stars shine in many different ways throughout their careers. Her allure was multifaceted, from her glamorous early days to her iconic comedic role, proving that some beauties truly transcend time and genre.

10. **Rock Hudson**Talk about a leading man! Rock Hudson was the epitome of tall, dark, and handsome, with a commanding presence that practically defined the golden age of Hollywood romance. His name alone conjures up images of sophisticated comedies and sweeping dramas, always with him at the center, radiating charisma.

Hudson was the dream boat that graced countless movie posters, captivating audiences with his dashing good looks and undeniable charm. He had that classic movie star appeal that made him an instant icon, gracing the screen with an air of effortless romance and strength.

It’s no wonder that he made such a lasting impression on generations of fans. Redditor u/CadabraMist shared a wonderfully relatable sentiment, stating, “My mom adored Rock Hudson.” And honestly, who could blame her? He was the kind of star who made you believe in movie magic and grand romances.

His ability to perfectly play the charming, often slightly bewildered romantic lead alongside screen legends like Doris Day cemented his status as a timeless heartthrob. Rock Hudson was, and still is, a quintessential figure of Hollywood’s romantic era, proving that some crushes simply never fade.

Shelley Winters in – ”The Chapman Report” 1962 – | Flickr, Photo by staticflickr.com, is licensed under CC BY-ND 4.0

11. **Shelley Winters**Now here’s a star whose trajectory might just surprise you! Shelley Winters, a name often associated with powerful, character-driven roles later in her career, was an absolute showstopper in her youth. She was a true chameleon, evolving her persona throughout her many decades in Hollywood.

As u/jeangaijin so aptly described her, “She was a knockout back in the day.” And truly, Winters possessed a vibrant, vivacious beauty that lit up the screen in her early films. It’s a wonderful reminder that many of our beloved character actors started out as dazzling leading ladies!

And here’s a juicy bit of Hollywood history for you: u/jeangaijin also reminds us that “She and Marilyn Monroe were roommates when they were both broke starlets, and shared shoes and clothes for auditions and screen tests.” Imagine that! Two future legends, sharing clothes and dreams, both on the cusp of superstardom. It just adds another layer of magic to her story.

Winters’ journey from glamorous young starlet to respected, Oscar-winning actress is a testament to her immense talent and adaptability. Her early beauty and later dramatic prowess prove that true star power is about much more than just a single look or phase. She was a talent that truly endured.

12. **Diahann Carroll**When we talk about elegance, grace, and undeniable poise, Diahann Carroll’s name shines brilliantly. She was a trailblazer, a captivating actress and singer whose sophisticated beauty and immense talent broke barriers and captivated audiences for decades.

Carroll possessed a radiant charm that was simply magnetic, whether she was gracing the stage or commanding the screen. Her presence was always imbued with an air of regal dignity and an intelligence that made her performances incredibly compelling. She was a true icon of style and substance.

Her beauty was not just skin deep; it radiated from a deep well of talent and confidence. She brought a unique blend of vulnerability and strength to her roles, making her an unforgettable figure in film and television history. It’s no wonder she’s remembered as a timeless beauty.

Diahann Carroll’s enduring appeal lies in her ability to project both glamour and genuine warmth. She proved that true attractiveness is a harmonious blend of stunning visuals and a powerful, intelligent spirit. She remains a beloved figure, a star whose light continues to inspire.

13. **Cesar Romero**Stepping onto our list with a dash of debonair charm and a mischievous glint in his eye is the one and only Cesar Romero! While younger generations might know him best for a certain iconic villain role, his early career was filled with suave, handsome turns that made women (and men!) swoon.

Romero had a distinctive screen presence, combining classic good looks with a lively, expressive energy. He was the kind of actor who could easily slip into a romantic lead, a charming rogue, or even a sophisticated man of mystery, always bringing his signature flair to the role.

His elegance and undeniable charisma made him a standout among the leading men of his time. He carried himself with an effortless sophistication that was incredibly appealing, proving that a sharp suit and a confident smile can go a very long way in the heartthrob department.

It’s a genuine shame that his earlier, dashing roles aren’t as widely celebrated today, because Romero truly embodied a unique brand of Hollywood attractiveness. His lasting appeal is a testament to that indelible charm and versatility that made him a beloved star for so many years.

14. **Myrna Loy**And finally, to round out our absolutely mind-blowing journey through Old Hollywood heartthrobs, we simply must talk about the magnificent Myrna Loy! She was the epitome of grace, wit, and captivating intelligence, a true star who lit up the screen with her effortless charm.

Loy wasn’t just beautiful; she possessed an undeniable sparkle and a comedic timing that was second to none. Redditor u/DatabaseThis9637 perfectly captures her essence: “Absolutely! She was gorgeous, elegant, and had a great comedic presence and timing.” She truly had it all, making her a formidable and unforgettable presence.

Her roles often showcased her sharp wit and sophisticated charm, particularly in classic screwball comedies where she played off her male counterparts with incredible ease. She was the kind of woman who was not only stunning but also incredibly smart and fun to watch.

Myrna Loy’s timeless appeal comes from that rare combination of outward beauty and inner sparkle. She taught us that a captivating smile, intelligent eyes, and a quick wit are just as, if not more, attractive than mere physical perfection. She remains an enduring icon, a star who proved that some qualities truly are ageless.

So, there you have it! A dizzying, delightful, and perhaps slightly age-accelerating tour through some of the most attractive stars Old Hollywood had to offer. It’s truly wild to see how these legends have changed over the years, but one thing remains crystal clear: true charisma, undeniable talent, and that special spark are absolutely timeless. These stars, whether in their youthful prime or seasoned later years, remind us that the allure of a genuine heartthrob never truly fades. Who knows, maybe you’ve just found your next (or first!) classic celebrity crush! Don’t forget to tell us in the comments who your favorite “forgotten” heartthrob is.