data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cf7ab/cf7ab7e6a5ff5c4e75fcf1040fbc8b09702d14dc" alt="woman in gray cardigan holding her face"
The world of makeup is transformative and powerful, allowing individuals to express themselves, highlight their natural beauty, and even combat signs of aging. However, there are certain pitfalls that many women over 40 unknowingly fall into, which can actually make them appear older. By avoiding these common mistakes and adopting expert-recommended techniques, you can achieve a more youthful, glowing look.
1. Steering Clear of the Sparkly Eyeshadow Trap: While glittery eyeshadow might sound like a fun way to add some glam to your look, it can unfortunately backfire for mature skin. The shimmer particles tend to settle into fine lines and wrinkles, highlighting them instead of masking them. For a more flattering alternative, consider matte shadows or those with a subtle sheen. They offer a sophisticated and polished appearance without drawing unwanted attention to aging signs.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ac7c7/ac7c7dd52c2f65656d6457c45973cff3a6ff31a2" alt="A mother is carefully applying eyeshadow to her daughter's closed eyes indoors."
2. Say No to Heavy Eyeliner: Thick layers of eyeliner can make your eyes look smaller and more drawn in, which is the opposite of the fresh, youthful look most aim for. Instead, choose a softer and more diffused line. Opting for browns or grays instead of harsh blacks can create a more delicate and natural look. Smudging the liner slightly also softens the effect and opens up the eyes.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/02456/02456c87ce13b204dfddb6f1685fbd428b642ca2" alt="woman with green eyes and brown eyes"
Product on Amazon: wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Retractable Gel Eyeliner – Waterproof 16-Hour Long-Lasting Wear, Cruelty-Free & Vegan – Brick Brown
Brand: wet n wild
Price: 2.79 USD
Rating: 4.3 Total reviews: 917
Top Review from US: “This eyeliner is INSANE. It absolutely stays put lol, lasts all day, the color payoff is gorgeous and it glides on smoothly!”
Shopping on Amzon >>
Read more about: The 13 Makeup Mistakes Older Women Make That Add Years to Your Face
3. Avoid Cakey Concealer: Overloading concealer can highlight imperfections rather than hide them. Instead of piling it under the eyes, use a lighter hand and blend it well. A creamy, hydrating formula works wonders in providing coverage while maintaining a natural finish. The focus should be on brightening the under-eye area, not masking it under heavy layers.
Product on Amazon: Benefit Boi-Ing Cakeless Concealer #4 Can’t Stop (Light Cool), 0.17 Ounce
Brand: Brand: Benefit
Price: 19.5 USD
Rating: 4.4 Total reviews: 709
Top Review from US: “The best concealer I’ve ever used!!! Covers & doesn’t leave creases. A bit pricey but well worth it!!!”
Shopping on Amzon >>
4. Skip the Powder Overload: While setting powder is crucial for keeping makeup in place, too much of it can settle into fine lines and create an undesired cakey finish. Opt for a translucent, finely-milled powder and apply it sparingly to areas that tend to get oily, such as the T-zone. The goal is to control shine without reducing your skin’s natural radiance.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/60322/603220a45f1fee7f4e234f684e1e995d03100b02" alt="three makeup brushes on top of compact powders"
5. Beware of the Wrong Foundation Formula: Selecting the right foundation is critical. Many women over 40 choose heavier foundations, thinking they offer better coverage. However, these can settle into lines and emphasize texture. A cream foundation is an excellent choice as it provides a velvety, smooth finish while offering buildable coverage that doesn’t feel heavy. It hydrates the skin and provides a more natural look.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/31e07/31e07bc895a83e7bd36d76f06bca6520f5e355a9" alt="Young adult using makeup sponge with a bug detail on the face and colorful hair."
Product on Amazon: Clinique Even Better Makeup Medium Coverage Foundation Broad Spectrum SPF 15 | Evens Skin Tone + Reduces Dark Spots
Price: 39 USD
Rating: 4.7 Total reviews: 11938
Top Review from US: “Great color, lasts long, Effortless application, great quality. It’s a little more expensive than what I normally get but this foundation is so worth it!”
Shopping on Amzon >>
6. Rethink Bronzer Application: Applying bronzer directly onto the skin without proper blending can lead to a patchy and uneven appearance. For a flawless finish, use a swirling motion on the back of your hand before applying it to your face. This ensures an even distribution of product, giving your skin a healthy, sun-kissed glow.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8b5e6/8b5e6cec81d83cadb4131d68cb36d49dc5d2d00f" alt="A detailed shot of a makeup palette with a brush applying eyeshadow, perfect for beauty and cosmetics themes."
Product on Amazon: Physicians Formula Murumuru Butter Bronzer, Moisturizing, Nourishing Murumuru Butter for Silky Glow, Dermatologist Tested, Hypoallergenic, Vegan & Cruelty-Free – Light Bronzer
Brand: Visit the Physicians Formula Store
Price: 11.99 USD
Rating: 4.5 Total reviews: 43059
Top Review from US: “Ok, I ordered this bronzer to use for intended purpose, but found its color too intense to look natural on my light skin tone. BUT, I found it worked perfectly for a blush. Creamy to blend with makeup base. Easy to blend so more natural looking. I’m a senior lady with rather sensitive skin. This is not to be ignored as “for old ladies” as it would work equally well on anyone. And it will last forever. I know “they” say throw makeup away after months or a year tops. Keep a clean applicator and I’ve never had an issue after using for a few years. Has not changes in any way!”
Shopping on Amzon >>
7. Lipstick Blunders: Dark or matte lipsticks can sometimes age your appearance by making lips look thinner and less vibrant. Instead, choose hydrating lipsticks or glosses with a bit of shine to give the illusion of fuller lips. Shades like soft pinks, corals, and nudes work beautifully in enhancing your natural lip color without overpowering your look.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/29895/29895a725653d4ca2f3af79de7b6dc57d552b372" alt="A stylish display of red lipsticks in gold tubes, capturing a chic and elegant look."
Product on Amazon: Monika Blunder Beauty Kissen Lush Lipstick Crayon – Valentina (Browny Muted Red) – Clean Beauty, Cruelty-Free, Vegan
Brand: Visit the Monika Blunder Beauty Store
Price: 32 USD
Rating: 3.7 Total reviews: 35
Top Review from US: “Don’t understand how this isn’t 5 stars?!?! It’s wonderful and stays on!!”
Shopping on Amzon >>
Makeup is an art form—one that evolves with you. By avoiding common mistakes you can enjoy a fresh, youthful look that enhances your natural beauty. Age is just a number, and with the right techniques, you can continue to shine, radiate, and feel beautiful at any age.
Related posts:
The 5 Worst Makeup Mistakes That Are ‘Ruining’ Your Look And What To Do For A ‘Lifted’ Face
‘It’s not helping you!’ Women over 60 told to avoid makeup mistake that is making them look ‘older’