For many Americans, purchasing a new SUV in 2024 represents one of the most significant financial commitments a household will make, with an average expenditure hovering around $47,000. This substantial investment often means buyers are navigating a landscape filled with marketing hype and alluring advertisements, which, unfortunately, can frequently obscure underlying mechanical issues, design deficiencies, and reliability problems. These hidden pitfalls have the potential to transform what was once a dream vehicle into an ongoing, costly nightmare.
Our journey through the automotive market today is guided by insights from trusted experts like Car and Driver and CarEdge. These authorities have consistently helped to pinpoint popular SUV models that, despite their widespread appeal, carry concerning track records. This guide is specifically designed to cut through the gloss and expose the often-overlooked problems inherent in certain common compact SUVs and crossovers—from critical transmission failures and confounding electrical gremlins to rapid depreciation and less-than-stellar safety scores. In a segment celebrated for its versatility and efficiency, not all vehicles deliver on their promises.
Crossovers, often lauded as the ideal blend of SUV spaciousness and car-like maneuverability, have become a go-to choice for urban drivers and families alike. They promise comfort, ease of handling, and often, better fuel economy than their larger SUV counterparts. However, not every crossover lives up to this enviable reputation for quality performance and cost-effectiveness. As we embark on this in-depth exploration, we’re setting aside the sales pitches to offer a candid, expert-backed assessment of compact crossovers that, based on extensive testing and reported issues, we are decidedly passing on the test drive.
1. **Hyundai Kona EV**
The 2024 Hyundai Kona EV, while often appealing due to its competitive pricing, unfortunately presents a series of significant practical limitations that detract from its overall value proposition. Despite the burgeoning interest in electric vehicles, this particular model struggles to deliver a refined experience, making it a challenging contender in its segment. It’s a classic example of a vehicle that looks promising on paper but falls short in real-world application.
One of the most noticeable drawbacks of the Kona EV is the considerable road noise penetration into the cabin, coupled with surprising levels of wind noise. This creates a less-than-serene driving environment, especially on highway journeys, where passengers might expect a quieter ride. Adding to this discomfort is the vehicle’s suspension tuning, which has been identified as particularly problematic; it exhibits a tendency to bounce excessively over pavement undulations, leading to poor handling characteristics that can noticeably impact passenger comfort and confidence.
Furthermore, the real-world efficiency of the Kona EV has been found to fall short of its EPA estimates. During testing, the vehicle achieved only 25 mpg, a figure lower than its rated specifications. This discrepancy means that potential savings on fuel might not materialize as expected. The driving experience itself can be challenging, as the vehicle proves particularly sensitive to aggressive driving styles, which, in turn, significantly impacts both its range and overall efficiency. To compound these issues, interior space utilization is compromised by certain design choices, limiting both passenger comfort and the practical capacity for cargo.
Car Model Information: 2024 Buick Enclave Premium FWD
Name: Hyundai Kona
Caption: Hyundai Kona N Line (SX2)
Manufacturer: Hyundai Motor Company
Aka: Hyundai Kauai (Portugal)
Production: 2017–present
ModelYears: 2018–present
Class: Subcompact crossover SUV
BodyStyle: SUV
Layout: ubl
Categories: 2020s cars, All-wheel-drive vehicles, All Wikipedia articles in need of updating, All Wikipedia articles written in British English, Articles containing Chinese-language text
Summary: The Hyundai Kona (Korean: 현대 코나) is a subcompact crossover SUV produced by the South Korean manufacturer Hyundai. The first-generation Kona debuted in June 2017 and the production version was revealed later that year. It is positioned between the Venue or Bayon and the Tucson in Hyundai crossover SUV line-up. The battery electric version called the Kona Electric (or Kona EV) was first launched in South Korea during the first half of 2018 and rolled out gradually worldwide afterwards.
Get more information about: Hyundai Kona
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Hyundai Model: Kona EV
Price: $29,997 Mileage: 37,000 mi.
Read more about: Are EVs Really Worth It? The 13 Downsides Nobody Tells You About Before You Buy
2. **MINI Countryman**
The MINI Countryman, with its undeniably distinctive styling and a strong sense of brand heritage, unfortunately cloaks fundamental design flaws that substantially impact its daily usability and the comfort of its occupants. While its aesthetic might turn heads, the practicality and ergonomic considerations seem to have taken a backseat, leading to a compromise in the overall driving experience that many buyers expect from a premium-priced compact crossover.
A primary ergonomic concern lies with the driving position, which is compromised by an offset steering wheel and limited reach adjustment, making it difficult for many drivers to find an optimal and comfortable setup. Adding to this, the design of the head restraints forces an uncomfortable forward-leaning posture, which can become increasingly apparent and bothersome during longer drives. These seemingly minor issues collectively detract significantly from the vehicle’s appeal as a daily driver, turning what should be an enjoyable ride into a source of discomfort.
Interior quality is another area where the Countryman struggles to meet expectations, particularly given its premium pricing. The cabin features numerous hard plastics throughout, which feel noticeably out of place in a vehicle attempting to position itself in the luxury-adjacent segment. Moreover, the practicality is further undermined by a high load lip, complicating cargo loading, and an overall poor utilization of interior space for a vehicle of its segment. While the Countryman can offer engaging handling characteristics, these dynamic capabilities often come at the expense of practical functionality and essential comfort, factors that many buyers prioritize in a compact SUV.
Car Model Information: 2019 MINI Countryman Cooper S ALL4
Name: MINI Countryman
Caption: 2018 Mini Countryman Cooper S (pre-facelift)
Manufacturer: BMW
Aka: Mini Crossover (Japan, until 2024)
Production: 2010–present
Class: Subcompact crossover SUV
BodyStyle: SUV
Layout: Front-engine, front-wheel-drive
Categories: 2020s cars, All-wheel-drive vehicles, All Wikipedia articles written in British English, All articles needing additional references, Articles needing additional references from May 2023
Summary: The Mini Countryman, also called Mini Crossover in Japan until 2024, is a subcompact crossover SUV, the first vehicle of this type to be launched by BMW under the Mini marque. It was launched in 2010 and received a facelift in 2014. The second generation vehicle was released in 2017 and received a facelift in 2020. The third generation of the Countryman was released in 2023.
Get more information about: Mini Countryman
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: MINI Model: Countryman
Price: $17,963 Mileage: 66,915 mi.
Read more about: Remember Them? 12 ‘Awkward’ Hatchbacks That Absolutely Owned the Road and Became Driver Favorites!
3. **Buick Envision**
The Buick Envision, despite its efforts to carve out a niche in the premium compact SUV segment, unfortunately carries surprisingly mediocre reliability, a factor that seriously undermines its perceived value proposition. While it does boast decently priced maintenance, averaging $2,776 over the first five years (which is notably lower than the industry average by $8,818), this positive aspect is overshadowed by a concerning 5% chance of requiring major repairs within the same period. This indicates a fundamental inconsistency in its build quality that potential buyers should heed.
Building on these concerns, the vehicle’s build quality has been particularly problematic in recent models, with widespread issues reported across its body hardware. These problems manifest in various components, including windows, door locks, latches, and even seat controls, suggesting a lack of robust engineering and assembly precision. Such persistent issues can lead to frequent visits to the service center, eroding the owner’s confidence and enjoyment of the vehicle, regardless of its lower average maintenance costs.
Beyond these mechanical and structural flaws, quality control issues extend to electrical troubles, dash light problems, and malfunctioning heated seats, all of which are commonly reported by owners. These persistent and varied build quality problems make it exceedingly difficult to justify the Envision’s premium positioning in the market. Buyers expecting a refined, trouble-free experience from a vehicle with a premium badge may find themselves deeply disappointed by the reality of its ownership.
Car Model Information: 2024 Buick Envision Preferred AWD
Name: Buick Envision
Manufacturer: Buick
Production: 2014–present
ModelYears: 2016–present (North America)
Assembly: Yantai
Class: Compact crossover SUV
BodyStyle: Sport utility vehicle
Layout: Front-engine, front-wheel-drive layout
Categories: 2010s cars, All-wheel-drive vehicles, All Wikipedia articles in need of updating, Articles with short description, Buick vehicles
Summary: The Buick Envision is a compact crossover SUV manufactured by General Motors and marketed under the Buick brand since 2014. It is exclusively manufactured in China by the SAIC-GM joint venture, supplying the Chinese and North American markets.
Get more information about: Buick Envision
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Buick Model: Envision
Price: $32,491 Mileage: 100 mi.
Read more about: Remember These? 14 Classic Cars From the 1980s That Everyone Forgot About (But Are Now Worth a Fortune!)
4. **Chevrolet Equinox (2018–2020)**
The Chevrolet Equinox models from 2018 to 2020 may present with a sleek exterior, but a closer look under the hood reveals significant mechanical shortcomings that make it a difficult recommendation for reliability. Specifically, the 1.5L turbo engine, a central component of these models, has been widely reported to burn oil and underperform, creating a notable disparity between its advertised capabilities and its real-world functionality. This engine issue forms the core of many owner complaints.
Owners of these Equinox models frequently report experiencing engine stalls and illumination of various warning lights, transforming what should be routine daily drives into stressful, unpredictable sessions. Such occurrences are not just inconvenient but can also be a significant safety concern. The consistent reports of these engine-related problems paint a picture of a powertrain that is simply not up to par, often requiring more attention and repair than buyers would anticipate from a relatively modern vehicle.
Furthermore, reliability scores for these specific model years of the Chevrolet Equinox have consistently fallen short of expectations, reflecting the recurring issues and owner dissatisfaction. This data strongly advises caution for anyone considering this vehicle. It is, quite simply, a “headache on wheels” that prospective buyers would be wise to skip, opting instead for a more dependable and less problematic compact crossover in the market.
Car Model Information: 2023 Chevrolet Equinox Premier
Name: Chevrolet Equinox
Manufacturer: General Motors
Aka: ubl
Production: 2004–present
ModelYears: 2005–present
Class: Mid-size crossover SUV
BodyStyle: Sport utility vehicle
Layout: Transverse engine,Front-engine, front-wheel-drive layout
Predecessor: ubl
Categories: 2000s cars, 2010s cars, 2020s cars, All-wheel-drive vehicles, All Wikipedia articles written in American English
Summary: The Chevrolet Equinox is a crossover SUV introduced by Chevrolet in 2004 for the 2005 model year. It was intended to replace the North American Chevrolet Tracker and Chevrolet S-10 Blazer. The third-generation Equinox also replaced the first-generation Chevrolet Captiva.
An all-electric battery-powered (BEV) version called the Equinox EV was introduced in 2022 with sales starting in 2023 for the 2024 model year. It adopts a separate design and underpinnings from the internal combustion engine powered Equinox.
Get more information about: Chevrolet Equinox
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Chevrolet Model: Equinox
Price: $28,488 Mileage: 12,043 mi.
Read more about: Decoding the Crossover Minefield: 14 Models Motorists Should Absolutely Avoid
5. **Jeep Cherokee (2014–2019)**
The Jeep Cherokee models from 2014 to 2019 were initially positioned as a technological leap for the brand, promising advanced features and a refined driving experience. However, this period for the Cherokee ultimately failed to deliver on that promise, largely due to profound issues with its much-touted 9-speed transmission. While the concept of a 9-speed transmission sounds sophisticated and efficient on paper, its implementation in these models proved to be anything but, quickly becoming a central point of frustration for owners.
This sophisticated transmission, rather than being an asset, turned out to be a significant liability—a veritable “mess,” as many have described it. Common complaints included harsh and jarring shifts, noticeable delays in response, and, most critically, widespread reports of outright transmission failures. These issues translated directly into a subpar and often unreliable driving experience, undermining the very essence of what a dependable vehicle should offer. The consistent nature of these problems indicates a fundamental flaw in design or manufacturing that was not easily rectified.
Consequently, the reliability ratings for these Jeep Cherokee models plummeted year after year, reflecting the persistent and unaddressed issues. Even subsequent updated models and attempted fixes were largely unable to shake off the stigma and the lingering problems associated with these early transmission woes. This particular generation of the Jeep Cherokee serves as a stark reminder that advanced technology must be robustly engineered and thoroughly tested to avoid becoming a frustrating detriment rather than an innovative improvement.
Car Model Information: 2022 Jeep Cherokee X
Name: Jeep Cherokee
Caption: Fifth generation (KL)
Manufacturer: Jeep
Aka: Jeep Liberty
ModelYears: unbulleted list
Class: unbulleted list
Layout: unbulleted list
Chassis: unbulleted list
Categories: All-wheel-drive vehicles, Anti-Indigenous racism in the United States, Articles with short description, Compact sport utility vehicles, Crossover sport utility vehicles
Summary: The Jeep Cherokee is a line of sport utility vehicles (SUV) manufactured and marketed by Jeep over six generations. Marketed initially as a variant of the Jeep Wagoneer (SJ), the Cherokee has evolved from a full-size station wagon (before the SUV description came into use) to one of the first compact SUVs and into its latest generation as a crossover SUV.
Named after the Cherokee tribe of Native Americans in the United States, Jeep has used the nameplate in some capacity since late 1973 when American Motors Corporation (AMC) introduced the 1974 model year line.
Production of the Cherokee ended in February 2023. The Cherokee nameplate has since been used by the Grand Cherokee and its extended version, the Grand Cherokee L.
Get more information about: Jeep Cherokee
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Jeep Model: Cherokee
Price: $24,725 Mileage: 26,492 mi.
Read more about: Decoding the Crossover Minefield: 14 Models Motorists Should Absolutely Avoid
6. **Ford EcoSport (All Years)**
The Ford EcoSport, across all its model years, often positions itself as a practical and economical choice for urban drivers and those seeking a compact crossover. However, this perception quickly dissipates once behind the wheel, as the vehicle tends to feel clumsy and less refined than its competitors. Its apparent practicality is overshadowed by a driving experience that frequently disappoints, failing to meet the contemporary expectations for comfort and agility in this popular segment.
One of the immediate drawbacks encountered by drivers is the notably stiff ride quality, which translates into a less-than-smooth journey, especially on uneven pavement. Adding to the discomfort, the interior space often feels more akin to a compact hatchback than a true crossover, leading to a cramped sensation that belies the vehicle’s exterior dimensions. This lack of interior volume compromises both passenger comfort and the practical utility expected from a crossover designed for versatility.
Further complicating daily use is a distinct design quirk: the rear door swings out sideways rather than lifting upwards. While perhaps unique, this design choice proves highly impractical, particularly in tight parking spots, where it can literally block access to the cargo area. This singular feature, combined with its overall clumsy feel and uninspired ride, makes the Ford EcoSport a problematic adventure that consistently falls short of providing a truly practical or enjoyable compact crossover experience.
Car Model Information: 2021 Ford EcoSport SE
Name: Ford EcoSport
Manufacturer: Ford Motor Company
Production: 2003–2022
ModelYears: 2014–2022 (Europe) ,2018–2022 (North America)
Class: Subcompact crossover SUV
BodyStyle: Sport utility vehicle
Layout: Front-engine, front-wheel-drive layout
Categories: 2010s cars, 2020s cars, All-wheel-drive vehicles, All articles with bare URLs for citations, All articles with unsourced statements
Summary: The Ford EcoSport ( EK-oh-sport) is a subcompact crossover SUV (B-segment) manufactured by Ford between 2003 and 2022.
The first-generation model was developed and built in Brazil by Ford Brazil since 2003, at the Camaçari plant. The second-generation model was launched in 2012, which was assembled in factories in India, Thailand, Russia and Romania. The vehicle entered the European market in 2014 and the North American market in 2018. It was sold in both until its discontinuation after the 2022 model year. Throughout its existence, the EcoSport shared its platform with the Fiesta.
Get more information about: Ford EcoSport
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Ford Model: EcoSport
Price: $12,425 Mileage: 96,879 mi.
Read more about: Decoding the Crossover Minefield: 14 Models Motorists Should Absolutely Avoid
7. **Nissan Rogue (2013–2018)**
The generation of Nissan Rogue models produced between 2013 and 2018 has earned a particularly unenviable reputation within the automotive community, becoming “infamous” for critical issues related to its Continuously Variable Transmission (CVT). This transmission, intended to provide smooth and efficient power delivery, instead became a significant Achilles’ heel for these vehicles, leading to widespread owner dissatisfaction and considerable financial burdens. It’s a prime example of a design flaw that deeply impacts the vehicle’s long-term viability.
Owners of these specific Rogue models frequently reported a range of severe CVT problems, including noticeable slipping, chronic overheating, and premature breakdowns. Such failures are not merely inconvenient; they are often incredibly costly, with repair bills for transmission issues typically running into thousands of dollars, making them a significant expense for owners. These widespread and consistent reports indicate a systemic flaw rather than isolated incidents, highlighting a critical reliability concern.
Beyond the pervasive transmission issues, which are undeniably the most severe, this generation of the Nissan Rogue also suffered from other less-than-stellar attributes. Its handling dynamics were generally described as dull and uninspired, lacking the responsiveness and engagement found in many rivals. Additionally, the interior quality was often considered mediocre, falling short of expectations for comfort and material refinement. While Nissan certainly offers many better options, such as the Murano or the newer Rogue models (post-2020), this particular generation stands out as one to approach with extreme caution, if not outright avoidance.”
Navigating the complex and often confusing world of compact crossovers requires a discerning eye, especially when the goal is to avoid costly mistakes. Having dissected the initial set of vehicles that simply don’t make the cut, we now continue our expert-backed journey to reveal more models that, despite their allure, are best left off your test-drive list. Our commitment remains firm: to provide the candid, objective evaluations that empower you to make truly informed purchasing decisions. Let’s delve into the next batch of compact crossovers that frequently fall short of expectations, impacting everything from performance and interior quality to overall long-term value. These are the vehicles that promise much but often deliver little beyond frustration.
Car Model Information: 2022 Nissan Rogue Sport SV
Name: Nissan Rogue
Caption: 2023 Nissan Rogue SV (US)
Manufacturer: Nissan
Aka: Nissan X-Trail
Production: 2007–present
ModelYears: 2008–present
Class: Compact crossover SUV
BodyStyle: SUV
Layout: Front-engine, front-wheel-drive layout
Predecessor: Unbulleted list
Categories: 2010s cars, All-wheel-drive vehicles, All articles containing circular references, All articles lacking reliable references, Articles lacking reliable references from November 2017
Summary: The Nissan Rogue is a compact crossover SUV produced by the Japanese automobile manufacturer Nissan. It made its debut in October 2007 for the 2008 model year. Beginning in 2013 for the 2014 model year, the model has been merged with the X-Trail sold outside the North American market, making them identical.
As of 2023, the Rogue was manufactured at the Nissan Smyrna Assembly Plant in Tennessee, United States and at the Nissan Motor Kyushu plant in Kanda, Fukuoka, Japan. Between August 2014 and March 2020, it was also built at the Renault Samsung Motors plant in Busan, South Korea under contract.
Get more information about: Nissan Rogue
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Nissan Model: Rogue
Price: $19,995 Mileage: 37,243 mi.
Read more about: Decoding the Crossover Minefield: 14 Models Motorists Should Absolutely Avoid
8. **Dodge Journey (All Years)**
The Dodge Journey is a prime example of a vehicle that, unfortunately, overstayed its welcome in the market. While its name suggests adventure, the reality of the Journey’s performance and comfort tells a very different story, often leaving drivers feeling that it simply doesn’t live up to its promise of long-distance capability. It consistently feels like a vehicle stuck in a past era, unable to keep pace with modern automotive advancements.
Under the hood, the Journey is frequently characterized by a sluggish engine, which contributes to a less-than-dynamic driving experience. This lack of responsiveness, combined with its outdated technology, tends to generate more yawns than genuine excitement from behind the wheel. For a segment that thrives on versatility and efficiency, the Journey struggles to make a compelling case for itself.
Ultimately, the Dodge Journey embodies the feeling of a crossover stuck in a time loop, unable to evolve with contemporary market expectations for performance, refinement, or technological integration. This unchanging nature means it consistently falls short when compared to more agile and technologically advanced competitors, rendering it a challenging choice for those seeking a modern and enjoyable driving experience.
Car Model Information: 2020 Dodge Journey SE Value
Name: Dodge Journey
Caption: 2012 Dodge Journey
Manufacturer: Dodge
Aka: Fiat Freemont,Dodge JC (Japan),Dodge JCUV (China)
Production: 2008–2020
ModelYears: 2009–2020,2011–2015 (Freemont)
Assembly: Toluca, Mexico
Designer: Ryan Nagode
Class: Mid-size crossover SUV
BodyStyle: SUV
Platform: Mitsubishi GS platform
Related: Chrysler 200,Chrysler Sebring,Dodge Avenger
Layout: Front-engine, front-wheel-drive layout
Engine: ubl
Transmission: Ultradrive#40TES/41TES
Wheelbase: 2890 mm
Abbr: on
Order: flip
Length: 192.4 in
Width: 72.2 in
Height: 66.6 in
Weight: 3818 lb
Predecessor: Fiat Ulysse,Fiat Croma
Successor: Dodge Journey (2021)
Categories: 2010s cars, 2020s cars, All-wheel-drive vehicles, All articles with dead external links, All articles with unsourced statements
Summary: The Dodge Journey is a mid-size crossover SUV manufactured and marketed by Fiat Chrysler Automobiles’ Dodge brand for model years 2009 to 2020 over a single generation, with a facelift for the 2011 model year. The Journey was styled by Ryan Nagode, and was marketed globally in both left- and right-hand drive, including as the Fiat Freemont.
Internally identified as the JC49, the Journey shares FCA’s global D-segment platform with the Dodge Avenger and a nearly identical wheelbase to the outgoing short-wheelbase (SWB) Dodge Caravan.
Having debuted at the 2007 Frankfurt Motor Show, the Journey subsequently appeared at the 2009 Frankfurt Motor Show. All models were manufactured in Mexico at FCA’s Toluca Assembly facility, with just over 1.1 million manufactured before production ended in 2020.
Get more information about: Dodge Journey
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Dodge Model: Journey
Price: $13,988 Mileage: 81,197 mi.
Read more about: Decoding the Crossover Minefield: 14 Models Motorists Should Absolutely Avoid
9. **Mitsubishi Outlander Sport (2011–2020)**
The Mitsubishi Outlander Sport models from 2011 to 2020 often leave drivers wanting more, particularly when it comes to interior refinement. The cabin lacks the thoughtful design and quality materials that have become standard in the compact crossover segment, making for a less than inspiring environment during daily commutes or longer trips. It’s a vehicle where the internal experience doesn’t quite match the expectations set by its exterior presence.
Performance-wise, the Outlander Sport struggles to impress, with its engine often droning under pressure, creating a noticeable lack of enthusiasm on the road. This strained powertrain, combined with a ride quality that turns bumpy during daily commutes, significantly detracts from passenger comfort and overall driving enjoyment. It’s an experience that can quickly wear on occupants, especially during extended periods behind the wheel.
In essence, the Mitsubishi Outlander Sport from this era is a basic crossover that simply doesn’t age well. Regardless of how low its initial price point might have been, the compromises in refinement, performance, and ride quality become increasingly apparent over time. For buyers seeking lasting satisfaction and modern amenities, this generation of the Outlander Sport proves to be a choice that ultimately underperforms.
Car Model Information: 2024 Buick Enclave Premium FWD
Categories: All set index articles, Articles with short description, Cars introduced in 2010, Mitsubishi Motors vehicles, Set index articles on cars
Summary: The Mitsubishi Outlander Sport is an automobile nameplate used by the Japanese automobile manufacturer Mitsubishi Motors since 2010 for several subcompact crossover SUV models:
Mitsubishi ASX, marketed as the Outlander Sport in the United States, Argentina, Brazil, and Indonesia since 2010
Mitsubishi Xforce, marketed as the Outlander Sport in the Americas and Africa since 2023
Get more information about: Mitsubishi Outlander Sport
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Mitsubishi Model: Outlander Sport
Price: $29,997 Mileage: 37,000 mi.
Read more about: Decoding the Crossover Minefield: 14 Models Motorists Should Absolutely Avoid
10. **Cadillac XT4 (2019–2021)**
When considering a luxury brand like Cadillac, buyers naturally anticipate a driving experience characterized by smoothness, quietness, and sophisticated engineering. However, the Cadillac XT4 models from 2019 to 2021 unfortunately defied these expectations, proving that a premium badge alone doesn’t guarantee a lavish or trouble-free ownership experience. It often felt more like a compromise than a true luxury offering.
These specific model years of the XT4 were plagued by a series of concerning issues, including reported brake problems and various tech bugs that could undermine user confidence. Adding to these operational woes was a jarring ride quality, which was particularly disappointing for a vehicle positioned in the luxury compact SUV segment. Such quirks significantly diminished the comfort and refinement buyers expected.
Ultimately, the Cadillac XT4 of this era demonstrated that buyers seeking true luxury and a seamless driving experience would find themselves receiving quirks rather than the anticipated comfort. It stands as a stark reminder that advanced technology and a prestigious name must be backed by robust engineering and thorough quality control to truly deliver on premium aspirations.
Car Model Information: 2023 Cadillac XT4 AWD Sport
Name: Cadillac XT4
Caption: Cadillac XT4
Manufacturer: General Motors
Production: 2018–present
ModelYears: 2019–present (China),2019–2025 (North America)
Assembly: Kansas City, Kansas
Designer: Therese Pinazzo (exterior)
Class: Subcompact luxury crossover SUV
BodyStyle: SUV
Layout: Front-engine, front-wheel-drive
Platform: GM Epsilon platform#E2XX
Related: Buick Envision
Engine: ubl
Transmission: GM 9T50 transmission
Wheelbase: 109.4 in
Abbr: on (FWD, est.)
Length: 181.1 in
Width: 74.1 in
Height: 64.1 in
Weight: 3660 lb
Categories: All Wikipedia articles written in American English, All articles with dead external links, All articles with unsourced statements, Articles with dead external links from August 2025, Articles with permanently dead external links
Summary: The Cadillac XT4 is a subcompact luxury crossover SUV manufactured by General Motors since the 2019 model year under the luxury Cadillac marque.
Get more information about: Cadillac XT4
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Cadillac Model: XT4
Price: $27,497 Mileage: 49,941 mi.
Read more about: Decoding the Crossover Minefield: 14 Models Motorists Should Absolutely Avoid
11. **Buick Encore (2013–2021)**
The Buick Encore, marketed as a small SUV designed for urban convenience, often proved to be a significant letdown for owners across its 2013-2021 model years. While its compact footprint might initially appeal, the vehicle struggled to deliver on essential aspects of performance and comfort that buyers in this segment typically prioritize. It often felt like a series of compromises rather than a well-rounded package.
Drivers frequently reported the Encore as feeling notably underpowered, making acceleration and highway merging a less-than-confident experience. Compounding this, the interior space often felt cramped, particularly in the rear seats, significantly limiting passenger comfort and practicality for families. These issues became more pronounced as the vehicle aged, affecting its long-term appeal.
What often begins as a sensible and affordable purchase can, unfortunately, transform into a frustrating ownership story as reliability tends to drop over the years. This consistent trend underscores an important lesson for prospective buyers: while a vehicle might appear “cute” or appealing in initial marketing, it doesn’t automatically equate to capable or dependable performance in the long run. The Encore serves as a cautionary tale for prioritizing substance over style.
Car Model Information: 2020 Buick Encore Preferred
Name: Buick Encore
Manufacturer: General Motors
Production: 2012–2022
ModelYears: 2013–2022
Class: Subcompact crossover SUV
BodyStyle: SUV
Successor: Buick Envista
Categories: 2010s cars, All-wheel-drive vehicles, All Wikipedia articles written in American English, Articles with short description, Buick vehicles
Summary: The Buick Encore is a subcompact crossover SUV built by General Motors from 2012 to 2022. It is subcompact crossover SUV marketed by Buick and its fourth SUV overall after the Rendezvous, Rainier, and Enclave.
The “Encore” designation was previously used by American Motors Corporation (AMC) for the subcompact two and four-door hatchback variants of the U.S.-built front-wheel drive Renault Alliance from 1984 to 1987.
Get more information about: Buick Encore
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Buick Model: Encore
Price: $14,990 Mileage: 64,227 mi.
Read more about: Decoding the Crossover Minefield: 14 Models Motorists Should Absolutely Avoid
12. **Land Rover Discovery Sport (2015–2019)**
Few things are more disheartening than investing in a vehicle that looks promising on paper but ultimately fails to deliver on its core promises. This was precisely the experience many drivers encountered with the Land Rover Discovery Sport models from 2015 to 2019. Despite its rugged brand image and sophisticated exterior, these models frequently left owners with significant reliability headaches rather than the expected robust performance.
Critical issues emerged, notably with the engine, which often failed to hold up well under normal operating conditions. This meant that what should have been a dependable and adventurous driving experience quickly turned unpredictable, eroding owner confidence. Such engine problems are not merely inconvenient; they can lead to substantial repair costs and prolonged downtime, truly testing an owner’s patience.
The persistent and often severe reliability issues meant that owners found themselves losing trust in their vehicle quite early in the ownership cycle. For a brand synonymous with exploration and durability, this generation of the Discovery Sport proved to be a significant misstep, failing to live up to the high standards and expectations associated with the Land Rover name. It stands as a potent reminder of the importance of proven reliability.
Car Model Information: 2024 Buick Enclave Premium FWD
Name: Land Rover Discovery Sport
Manufacturer: Jaguar Land Rover
Production: 2014–present
ModelCode: L550
Assembly: Jaguar Land Rover Halewood,Changshu,Itatiaia,Pune
Designer: Gerry McGovern
Platform: Jaguar Land Rover car platforms#D8
Related: Range Rover Evoque,Jaguar E-Pace,Tata Harrier
Engine: ubl
Motor: ubl
Transmission: ubl
Wheelbase: Convert
Length: Convert
Width: Convert
Height: Convert
Weight: Convert
Sp: uk
Class: Compact crossover SUV#Luxury vehicles
BodyStyle: SUV
Layout: unbulleted list
Predecessor: Land Rover Freelander
Categories: 2020s cars, All-wheel-drive vehicles, All Wikipedia articles written in British English, Articles with short description, CS1: unfit URL
Summary: The Land Rover Discovery Sport (internal code L550) is a compact luxury crossover SUV produced by British automotive company Jaguar Land Rover since 2014, under their Land Rover marque, and since 2017 their best-selling model.
Introduced in late 2014, it replaces the Freelander in a revised Land Rover range of vehicles, with Discovery joining Range Rover as a sub-brand. Contrary to its predecessor, the slightly larger car is also available in a seven seat layout.
The pre-facelift Discovery Sport is based on the JLR D8/LR-MS platform, customised for off-road applications, and is powered by a range of four cylinder petrol and diesel engines. It is the first Discovery built with a unibody structure.
Land Rover described the facelifted Discovery Sport as being based on the JLR PTA platform, a rebrand of the D8. It is also used by the Jaguar E-Pace and L551 version of Range Rover Evoque.
Get more information about: Land Rover Discovery Sport
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Land Rover Model: Discovery Sport
Price: $29,997 Mileage: 37,000 mi.
Read more about: Decoding the Crossover Minefield: 14 Models Motorists Should Absolutely Avoid
13. **Hyundai Tucson (2016–2018)**
The Hyundai Tucson models produced between 2016 and 2018 presented prospective buyers with a particularly alarming issue: the phrase “engine seizure” became an unfortunate part of the ownership vocabulary. A documented defect in these crossovers caused engines to fail, sometimes quite suddenly, transforming what should be a reliable family vehicle into a source of considerable stress and potential danger.
While Hyundai did respond by extending warranties for affected vehicles, the underlying stress and inconvenience of such a critical mechanical failure are undeniable. This situation serves as a stark reminder that in the automotive world, newer technology or appealing aesthetics don’t always equate to superior reliability, especially when systemic defects are present across specific model years.
Beyond these severe engine problems, this generation of the Tucson also struggled with performance and efficiency. It often delivered sluggish acceleration, even with its four-cylinder engine, making for an uninspired driving experience. Furthermore, its fuel economy, particularly for all-wheel-drive models, hovered around an estimated 25 mpg combined, which placed it at the lower end of the spectrum for compact crossovers.
Individual driver reviews frequently echoed these concerns, noting persistent poor gas mileage and a worrying trend of transmission issues occurring even in vehicles driven less than 25,000 miles. These reports indicate a pattern of reliability challenges that extended beyond the initial engine seizure defect, underscoring broader quality concerns for the 2016-2018 Tucson.
Car Model Information: 2024 Hyundai TUCSON SEL
Name: Hyundai Tucson
Caption: Hyundai Tucson (NX4, SWB)
Manufacturer: Hyundai Motor Company
Aka: Hyundai ix35 (2009–2015)
Production: 2004–present
ModelYears: 2005–present
Class: Compact crossover SUV
BodyStyle: sport utility vehicle
Layout: Front-engine, front-wheel-drive layout,Front-engine, four-wheel-drive layout
Sp: us
Categories: 2010s cars, All-wheel-drive vehicles, All Wikipedia articles written in British English, All articles needing additional references, All articles with dead external links
Summary: The Hyundai Tucson (; Korean: 현대 투싼) is a compact crossover SUV produced by the South Korean manufacturer Hyundai. It is named after the city of Tucson, Arizona, U.S.
The second-generation model was marketed as the Hyundai ix35 in several markets, including Europe, Australia and China, before reverting to Tucson for the third-generation. Since its first-generation, the Tucson has been developed alongside the Kia Sportage, sharing platforms and engines.
The Tucson is the best-selling Hyundai model, with more than 7 million units sold globally since it launched in 2004. Of these, 1.4 million units have been sold in Europe.
Get more information about: Hyundai Tucson
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Hyundai Model: Tucson
Price: $22,590 Mileage: 45,411 mi.
Read more about: Decoding the Crossover Minefield: 14 Models Motorists Should Absolutely Avoid
14. **Kia Sportage**
The Kia Sportage, while often lauded for its contemporary styling, has unfortunately demonstrated significant shortcomings in performance, particularly as highlighted in Car and Driver’s testing. It performed poorly in critical evaluations, suggesting that its outward appearance belies an underlying lack of dynamic capability and engineering refinement that modern drivers expect from a compact crossover.
A primary concern for the Sportage is its noticeable lack of power, especially with the base 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine. This powertrain frequently struggles on uphill grades, demanding significant effort from the engine to maintain momentum. The result is often slow acceleration and a feeling of strain, which can detract from confidence and enjoyment, particularly in demanding driving conditions.
Adding to these performance issues is the vehicle’s disappointing fuel economy. Car and Driver testing revealed an average of 25-mph, a figure that certainly won’t save buyers much money at the gas pump. In a segment where efficiency is a key selling point, the Sportage’s performance in this area further diminishes its overall value proposition, making it a challenging recommendation for cost-conscious consumers.
Car Model Information: 2021 Kia Sportage EX
Name: Kia Sportage
Manufacturer: Kia
Production: 1993–present
Class: Compact SUV
BodyStyle: SUV
Predecessor: Kia Retona
Layout: Front-engine, rear-wheel-drive,Front-engine, front-wheel-drive,Front-engine, all-wheel-drive
Chassis: ubl
ModelYears: 1995–present
Categories: 2000s cars, 2010s cars, ANCAP small off-road, All-wheel-drive vehicles, All Wikipedia articles written in British English
Summary: The Kia Sportage (Korean: 기아 스포티지) is a series of automobiles manufactured by the South Korean manufacturer Kia since 1993 through five generations. Initially a compact SUV built on a body-on-frame chassis, the second-generation Sportage transitioned to a car-based platform which placed it into the compact crossover SUV class, and was originally developed alongside the Hyundai Tucson and since the fifth-generation model launched in 2021, in two sizes with different wheelbase lengths for different markets, alongside the Hyundai Santa Fe and the Kia Sorento.
The Sportage has been the best-selling Kia model globally since 2016 after surpassing the Rio. In 2018, the model reached the 5 million production milestone. As of 2023, the Sportage is positioned between the Seltos or Niro and the three-row Sorento in Kia’s SUV global lineup with the latter sharing platform with the Sportage.
Get more information about: Kia Sportage
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: Kia Model: Sportage
Price: $18,590 Mileage: 28,680 mi.
Read more about: The Gold Standard vs. The Graveyard: A Deep Dive into 10 Used Crossovers Dealers Love (and Loathe)
15. **GMC Terrain**
Prospective buyers might want to exercise considerable caution before committing to the GMC Terrain, especially considering Kelley Blue Book’s assessment that this crossover consistently lacked strong competition in most testing areas. While the 2024 Terrain does offer a turbocharged 4-cylinder engine and a spacious interior, these positives are often overshadowed by several critical drawbacks that impact its overall appeal.
One significant area of concern lies within the cabin, where despite its spaciousness, the interior features an abundance of hard plastics. This choice of materials feels notably out of place when compared to similarly priced compact crossovers, failing to deliver the premium feel that buyers might anticipate. Such design decisions can significantly detract from the perceived quality and comfort of the vehicle.
Adding to the frustration, KBB found the Terrain’s push-button transmission controls to have a steep learning curve. The horizontally arranged buttons proved challenging to operate, making routine maneuvers like three-point turns unnecessarily complex and unintuitive. This design flaw highlights a lack of ergonomic foresight that can quickly become a daily inconvenience for drivers.
While GMC plans a redesigned 2025 Terrain, potentially offering improvements, the current model struggles to present a compelling case in a fiercely competitive market. Its shortcomings in interior material quality, challenging transmission controls, and overall lack of standout performance make it a vehicle that requires careful consideration before purchase.
Car Model Information: 2024 GMC Terrain SLT
Name: GMC Terrain
Manufacturer: General Motors
Production: August 2009 – present
ModelYears: 2010–present
Class: Mid-size crossover SUV
Layout: Transverse engine,Front-engine, front-wheel-drive layout
Predecessor: GMC Envoy,Pontiac Torrent,Opel Antara
BodyStyle: SUV
Categories: 2010s cars, All-wheel-drive vehicles, All Wikipedia articles written in American English, Articles with short description, Cars introduced in 2009
Summary: The GMC Terrain is a crossover SUV by American manufacturer General Motors under its GMC marque. Sharing its platform with the Chevrolet Equinox, the first-generation Terrain was built on GM’s Theta platform, while subsequent generations are built on the Delta platform. The Terrain is the smallest GMC vehicle, slotted below the Acadia. It also indirectly replaced the Pontiac Torrent which was typically sold via the same dealers prior to General Motors dropping the Pontiac brand.
Get more information about: GMC Terrain
Buying a high-performing used car >>>
Brand: GMC Model: Terrain
Price: $23,490 Mileage: 50,531 mi.
Read more about: The 15 Most Reliable Pickup Trucks of 2025 Ranked by Owner Survey
So, as you navigate the complex landscape of compact crossovers, remember that the shiny brochures and enticing advertisements often tell only half the story. Our deep dive into these problematic models isn’t meant to deter you from the crossover segment entirely, but rather to arm you with the expert insights needed to make a truly informed decision. Trusting reputable sources, understanding common pitfalls, and prioritizing real-world performance over marketing fluff will ultimately lead you to a vehicle that brings joy, not headaches, for years to come. Your hard-earned money deserves a ride that delivers on its promises, not one you’ll regret at every turn.
