In the sprawling, often overwhelming, landscape of the supermarket freezer aisle, where a kaleidoscope of ice cream varieties beckons, how does one truly distinguish the remarkable from the merely acceptable? From time-honored vanilla and chocolate to innovative new flavors, the sheer abundance can leave even the most ardent ice cream aficionado in a delicious dilemma. But fear not, for who better to guide us through this frosty wonderland than the very maestros of taste themselves – professional chefs? These culinary experts, with their acutely refined palates and profound understanding of ingredients and preparation, possess an unparalleled ability to discern the nuances that elevate a simple frozen treat into an extraordinary indulgence. They are not merely seeking a sugar rush; they are on a quest for perfection, driven by a deep appreciation for craft and quality.
Our journey into the minds of these culinary virtuosos reveals that their choices are far from arbitrary. Their strong opinions are rooted in fundamental principles of gastronomy, focusing on critical elements like texture, creaminess, and the thoughtful integration of mix-ins. While big-name brands such as Ben & Jerry’s and Häagen-Dazs frequently grace their selections, it’s fascinating to observe that many chefs also champion smaller, local brands and even cherished nostalgic throwbacks. There’s an underlying philosophy that governs their preferences, a set of unspoken rules that dictate what truly makes an ice cream not just good, but genuinely exceptional. This isn’t just about personal taste; it’s about a scientific, almost artistic, approach to frozen dessert.
At the very heart of a chef’s discerning evaluation lies the paramount importance of texture. This isn’t merely about mouthfeel; it’s about the entire sensory experience. Kaitlyn Lloyd, pastry chef at Stillwater and Sloane’s in Boston, articulates this perfectly when she declares her enduring loyalty to Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia, stating, “It’s got such a solid balance of flavors without being overly sweet and satisfies everything I need texture-wise. Plus it’s consistently generous with big chunks of chocolate and cherries.” Her emphasis on texture being satisfied alongside flavor balance highlights that the tactile sensation is as crucial as the taste itself. A truly great ice cream must deliver on both fronts, providing a harmonious and pleasing experience from the first spoonful to the last.
Salvatore Martone, executive pastry chef at The Bastion Collection, echoes this sentiment regarding Ben & Jerry’s Chunky Monkey, finding delight in its tactile engagement. “What really draws me in is the texture—it’s fun to dig in and find those crunchy pieces,” Martone enthuses. He adds, “The mix of smooth and crunchy keeps me coming back for more. It’s a tried-and-true simple pleasure that’s always satisfying.” This highlights the value of contrast within the ice cream itself – the smooth, creamy base providing a counterpoint to delightful, often surprising, textural elements. It transforms a passive eating experience into an active, exploratory one, making each bite an adventure.
The distribution and integrity of these textural elements are also key. Carlo Mirarchi, chef at Foul Witch, Roberta’s, and Blanca in New York City, delivers high praise for Häagen Dazs Chocolate Chocolate Chip, singling out its “unbelievably perfect distribution of chocolate chips–the ratio is absolute perfection.” He even notes, with a hint of playful expertise, “You can eat it with a fork.” This illustrates that for chefs, the thoughtful engineering of mix-ins is not an afterthought but a critical component of the ice cream’s overall success. It’s about ensuring every spoonful delivers the intended experience, without an imbalance of too much or too little of any single component.
Beyond just chips and chunks, the inclusion of ingredients that offer a distinctive crunch or chew is highly valued. Nic Vanderbeeken, chef at Apéritif restaurant in Bali, extols Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream Brown Butter Almond Brittle flavor, appreciating how “it strikes a perfect balance between rich, nutty sweetness and the satisfying crunch of the brittle.” This exemplifies how textural elements are not just present for their own sake, but contribute to a larger, more complex flavor profile. The crunch of the brittle isn’t merely a distraction; it’s an enhancement, adding depth and dimension to the overall taste sensation.
Kat Williams, chef and owner of Detroit’s Lady of the House, finds similar joy in the textural interplay of Milk Bar Cereal Milk. She cherishes “the combination of salty and sweet, as well as the little bit of crunch from the cornflakes and the toasted oat crust in each.” This shows that texture can also evoke a sense of playfulness and nostalgia, bringing back memories of childhood breakfast bowls transformed into a sophisticated dessert. The unexpected crunch offers a delightful surprise, making the experience more engaging and memorable.
Underpinning all these sensory observations is a fundamental, non-negotiable principle for chefs: the integrity of the ingredients. Tom Cenci, Executive Chef at Maslow’s, states it unequivocally: “When choosing ice cream, the non-negotiable factor is real, natural ingredients. The ingredients list should be straightforward and recognisable, without excessive preservatives.” This isn’t just a preference; it’s a foundational demand that speaks to a deeper culinary philosophy. Chefs, by their very nature, understand that truly exceptional flavor begins with exceptional raw materials, untainted by artificial additives.
Chef Sohan Bhandari from luxury celebrity hotspot Colonel Saab reiterates this critical point, emphasizing the importance of authenticity. He asserts, “If I can taste real ingredients, like proper Madagascan vanilla or freshly roasted nuts’s when I know it’s a quality product.” This highlights the intuitive connection between high-quality ingredients and a superior taste experience. For these experts, the proof is not just in the pudding, but in the purity of its components. This deep appreciation for ingredient sourcing is a hallmark of serious culinary evaluation.
Nowhere is this commitment to real ingredients more evident than in the seemingly simple, yet profoundly complex, world of vanilla ice cream. While many ice creams boast a vanilla flavor, chefs are unanimous on a crucial detail: the presence of genuine vanilla seed pods. These tiny black flecks are not just a visual cue; they are the undisputed mark of authenticity. Dean Harper, the culinary maestro behind Harper Fine Dining, champions Häagen-Dazs Vanilla Bean, specifically praising its “balance between sweetness and flavour without anything artificial overpowering the taste.” He insists, “It’s simple with real vanilla seeds and a deep, natural flavour that feels indulgent without being cloying.” This detail, the tangible evidence of true vanilla, elevates the product from a mere flavoring to a genuine expression of a premium ingredient.
Sohan Bhandari confirms this standard, pointing to Green & Black’s Organic Vanilla as a prime example because “It’s got that proper custard base, with flecks of real vanilla bean.” The emphasis on a “proper custard base” further underscores the commitment to traditional, high-quality preparation methods that contribute to superior texture and flavor. The combination of authentic vanilla and a rich base is what sets apart the truly stellar vanilla ice creams.
The global benchmark for vanilla, Madagascan vanilla, also known as Bourbon vanilla, is consistently referenced by chefs for its “full-bodied, creamy essence that sets the bar high.” This particular varietal is prized for its rich, complex flavor profile that provides a deep, authentic vanilla taste without being overly sweet or artificial. It is the gold standard for a reason, delivering a pure and intense aroma that cannot be replicated by extracts alone. This scientific understanding of ingredient origin is crucial for chefs who seek true excellence.
Other notable endorsements for authentic vanilla include Dominique Woolf, founder of Woolf’s Kitchen, who praises Hackney Gelato’s Madagascan Vanilla for being “super creamy and full of proper vanilla flavour.” Mark Hartstone, chef proprietor of La Fosse at Cranborne, describes Purbeck Vanilla bean as “consistently smooth, rich, and made not far from home,” again highlighting both texture and authenticity. Jack Pearce, Head Chef at Tom Browns restaurant in Gunthorpe, Nottingham, gives his nod to Thaymar’s Clotted Cream and Vanilla, hailing it as “a perfect twist on a British classic.” The consensus is clear: if it’s vanilla, it better be real vanilla.
Turning our attention to the dark, decadent world of chocolate ice cream, chefs again emphasize a specific characteristic: “cocoa richness without it turning cloying.” This means a deep, true chocolate flavor that is intense and satisfying, yet avoids being overly sweet or heavy. Jack Pearce of Tom Browns and Dean Harper both agree that Häagen-Dazs Belgian Chocolate tub is “rich, indulgent, and unbeatable.” This particular flavor is celebrated for delivering that profound cocoa experience without becoming tiresome or sugary.
Product on Amazon: Haagen-Dazs Ice Cream, Chocolate Chocolate Chip, 14 oz (Frozen)
Brand: Brand: Häagen-Dazs
Price: 3.49 USD
Rating: 4.7 Total reviews: 1256
Features:
1. Haagen-Dazs Chocolate Chocolate Chip Ice Cream is a doubly decadent experience
2. The perfect combination of rich chocolate chips folded into our iconic chocolate ice cream
3. One 14 oz. carton
4. Haagen-Dazs Ice Cream is always made with milk and cream from cows not treated with the growth hormone rBST*
5. Certified Kosher and no GMO ingredients
Shopping on Amazon >>
Dean Harper also confesses a fondness for Valrhona Chocolate Ice Cream, noting that it tantalizes the taste buds with its high-end cocoa that offers “a delightful balance of bitter and sweet.” This balance is key – a good chocolate ice cream shouldn’t just be sweet; it should showcase the complex, sometimes slightly bitter, notes of high-quality cocoa. Sohan Bhandari echoes this, stating that the best chocolate ice creams share this common trait of “cocoa richness without it turning cloying.” It’s about savoring the true essence of chocolate, not just its sweetness.
Beyond individual flavors, chefs often seek an overall balance in their ice cream selections. Sohan Bhandari precisely defines this balance as “richness without being heavy, sweetness that doesn’t overpower, and a texture that’s smooth.” This holistic view speaks to the intricate interplay of all sensory components. It’s about creating a harmonious experience where no single element dominates, but rather all contribute to a cohesive and satisfying whole. This equilibrium is what elevates an ice cream from merely palatable to truly memorable.
For many chefs, however, the choice of a favorite ice cream transcends purely objective criteria like texture, ingredients, and balance; it often delves into the deeply personal realm of nostalgia. The flavors of childhood summers, holiday traditions, and special family moments frequently shape their preferences, proving that taste is inextricably linked to memory and emotion. Rochelle Cooper, pastry chef at The Duck & The Peach, La Collina, The Wells and Meli in Washington, D.C., fondly recalls Ben and Jerry’s Chunky Monkey as a nostalgic pick. “Ben and Jerry’s Chunky Monkey is my favorite flavor because I used to eat it and watch Nickelodeon as a kid growing up,” Cooper shares. “I remember digging around for the big chocolate chunks, and eating so much just because I kept looking for them.” This isn’t just a flavor; it’s a time machine.
Product on Amazon: Valrhona Dulcey Blond Chocolate Feves from OliveNation – 1/2 pound
Brand: Visit the VALRHONA Store
Price: 26.99 USD
Rating: 4.7 Total reviews: 128
Flavor: Vanilla
Item Weight: 8 Ounces
Specialty: baking-chocolates
Item Form: Powder
Features:
1. Valrhona Dulcey Blond Chocolate Feves from OliveNation have creamy texture and a delicious taste that is not too sweet with intense biscuity flavors
2. Made with 32% Cocoa butter, sugar, whole milk powder, dried skimmed milk, whey, butter, emulsifier (soya lecithin), natural vanilla extract.
3. Dulcey is a smooth,creamy caramelized white chocolate with a warm, blond color and unique taste that is buttery, toasty and not too sweet, gradually giving way to a hint of salt.
4. Dulcey can be used in Ganache, mousse, ice-cream, & sorbets, Chocolate beverages, Molding, chocolate sauces, Decoration, Glazing & Cremeux
5. Packaging Note: For your convenience OliveNation will sometimes re-package products into smaller size containers. Therefore, ingredients we distribute from other brands may not arrive in the original manufacturer packaging.
Shopping on Amazon >>
Angel Perez of BE Pasta Bar in Brookline, Mass., finds a similar connection with Häagen-Dazs Dulce de Leche, which transports him back to his homeland in Guatemala. “Caramel is a delicacy in the Guatemalan culinary tradition and is often used for special and religious occasions in the form of candies,” Perez explains. “When I take a bite of Häagen-Dazs’ Dulce de Leche ice cream, it brings me back to my country.” The power of food to evoke cultural heritage and personal history is a profound aspect of culinary appreciation, even for a simple pint of ice cream.
Seasonal treats also hold a special place in these culinary hearts, often tied to cherished family traditions. Tab Volpe, executive pastry chef for The Banks, Bistro du Midi and Harvest in Boston, is especially fond of Friendly’s Jubilee Roll. “Friendly’s Jubilee Roll always signaled Christmas time in my household, the roll would last a weekend, between my dad and myself and siblings,” Volpe recounts. “The chocolate chip ice cream base with a chocolate center and the fudge lines on top with candied almonds was my favorite part.” This connection to specific times and memories adds a layer of warmth and sentimentality to the enjoyment of ice cream, making it more than just a dessert.
Volpe also shares a strong nostalgic link to Hood Rainbow Sherbet, a New England classic. “My all-time favorite is Hood Rainbow Sherbet, buying it in the big tub and eating spoonfuls brings me back to my childhood summers,” he says of the orange, lemon, and lime striped treat. The simple act of eating this sherbet becomes a portal to past joys, demonstrating how certain flavors are woven into the fabric of one’s personal history. Chef Nayibe Renaud, executive pastry chef at Komodo Las Vegas, mirrors this sentiment, declaring, “Baskin Robbins Cherry Jubilee will forever be my favorite nostalgic flavor and brand.”
Product on Amazon: Haagen-Dazs, Dulce De Leche Ice Cream, 14 oz (Frozen)
Brand: Brand: Häagen-Dazs
Price: 5.49 USD
Rating: 4.8 Total reviews: 1846
Features:
1. All Natural
2. Made From the best ingredients on Earth
3. 14 oz
Shopping on Amazon >>
Jackie Alpers, chef and cookbook author, discovered Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream Wildberry Lavender through a whimsical, nostalgic journey inspired by a movie. “Wildberry Lavender has been around for over 20 years but I didn’t discover it until I went looking for a blue ice cream for a blue tinted ice cream float inspired by the narwhal in the movie Elf,” Alpers explains. Despite the wildberry being more purple, she notes the flavor “tastes like summer and personifies the color lavender,” showcasing how even new discoveries can quickly become infused with a sense of wonder and personal association, linking them to specific moods or experiences.
Chef Carl Dooley of Mooncusser and Moon Bar in Boston, finds New England nostalgia in Friendly’s Orange Creme Roll Ice Cream & Sherbet Roll, calling it a “perfect mix of delicious creamsicles vibes.” He adds, “I love to bring this to a party, everyone’s face lights up, you feel like a kid, and it’s super easy to serve to a crowd.” This speaks to the ice cream’s power to evoke shared joy and a collective sense of youthful abandon. Similarly, Aidan Mc Gee, chef at The Dubliner and McGonagle’s Pub, shares that a scoop of Kell’s Kreme mint chocolate chip “brings me back to the seaside in Ireland as a kid,” underscoring the deep, cross-cultural power of ice cream to transport us through time and space via memory.
Adam Young, owner and chef of Sift Bake Shop in Connecticut, sums up the allure of heritage brands like Warwick Ice Cream, noting, “The classic technique and even packaging lends to nostalgia of year’s past.” He highlights how elements beyond the taste itself – the brand’s history, its presentation – can contribute to that powerful, comforting sense of nostalgia. It’s not just about what’s in the pint, but the story and memories it carries.
Product on Amazon: Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams Brown Butter Almond Brittle Ice Cream, 16 oz (Frozen)
Brand: Brand: Jeni’s
Price: 9.99 USD
Rating: 4.6 Total reviews: 1554
Shopping on Amazon >>
Ultimately, when professional chefs weigh in on their favorite ice creams, they offer far more than just a list of beloved flavors. They provide a masterclass in discernment, a rigorous yet passionate exploration into what truly makes a frozen dessert exceptional. Their insights underscore that the best ice cream is a delicate alchemy of superior ingredients, masterful technique, harmonious textures, and often, a powerful emotional resonance. Their trained palates and deep understanding of culinary science cut through the marketing fluff, guiding us toward products that truly deliver on their promise of indulgence and satisfaction. They challenge us to look beyond the surface, to appreciate the craftsmanship in every scoop, and to discover the profound pleasure that comes from a truly well-made ice cream. So, the next time you find yourself staring at that vast freezer aisle, remember the wisdom of these chefs, and choose not just a flavor, but an experience. Their recommendations are not just preferences; they are a testament to the pursuit of frozen perfection.
Having explored the rigorous criteria that guide professional chefs in their quest for the perfect scoop, it’s time to pull back the curtain on their actual prized possessions. Beyond the philosophical underpinnings of texture, ingredients, and balance, what specific pints grace the freezers of these culinary maestros? It’s a fascinating mix of universally recognized giants and beloved local treasures, all chosen for reasons that transcend mere flavor to encompass a symphony of sensory and emotional satisfaction.
Leading the charge, as might be expected, are the iconic labels that have long dominated the ice cream landscape. Ben & Jerry’s, a brand synonymous with generous mix-ins and imaginative flavor combinations, garners significant adoration. Kaitlyn Lloyd, a pastry chef in Boston, remains a loyal “Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia girl” praising its “solid balance of flavors without being overly sweet” and how it “satisfies everything I need texture-wise,” consistently delivering “big chunks of chocolate and cherries.” Even the lighter Froyo take on Cherry Garcia is lauded by Sue Olson for its classic, bright, and rich flavor. This widespread appeal speaks volumes about the brand’s consistent quality and its ability to hit all the right notes for discerning palates.
Another staple from the Ben & Jerry’s lineup that consistently appears on chefs’ lists is Chunky Monkey. Salvatore Martone, executive pastry chef at The Bastion Collection, is captivated by its tactile engagement, remarking, “What really draws me in is the texture—it’s fun to dig in and find those crunchy pieces.” He emphasizes that “the mix of smooth and crunchy keeps me coming back for more. It’s a tried-and-true simple pleasure that’s always satisfying.” The brand’s Milk & Cookies flavor also finds a champion in Adam Resnick, executive chef at Bambara Kitchen & Bar, who adores “the swirls of chocolate cookie dough” and “the texture with cookie dough globs!” It’s clear that Ben & Jerry’s excels at crafting an engaging, multi-faceted ice cream experience.
Häagen-Dazs, often celebrated for its commitment to simplicity and quality, also earns high praise from the culinary community. Angel Perez of BE Pasta Bar is deeply connected to Häagen-Dazs Dulce de Leche, which serves as a delicious reminder of his Guatemalan heritage, where “caramel is a delicacy in the Guatemalan culinary tradition and is often used for special and religious occasions.” He shares that “When I take a bite of Häagen-Dazs’ Dulce de Leche ice cream, it brings me back to my country,” highlighting the profound cultural resonance a simple dessert can hold. This emotional connection is a powerful testament to the brand’s ability to transcend mere taste.
Anthony Mangieri, founder of Una Pizza Napoletana, expresses awe for Häagen-Dazs Strawberry, noting its ability “to consistently create a great product” even at scale. He finds it “incredible that they’ve been able to scale it and it’s available in every store, and yet it’s still an amazing product.” Mangieri admires its minimalist approach—“It has so few ingredients, it has a perfect texture, and tastes great frozen solid or when you let it soften”—ultimately concluding that “To me, they’ve raised the bar for what a mass-produced product could be.” This appreciation for consistency and quality, even in widely available products, is a recurring theme among these experts.
Beyond these titans, chefs also enthusiastically champion the innovative and artisanal creations of Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream. David Rose, executive chef at Omaha Steaks, can’t get enough of Jeni’s Salty Caramel, calling it his go-to “whenever I have a sweet tooth for a cold treat.” He extols its “homemade” taste and “the perfect balance of sweet and savory, and super-creamy with a hint of sea salt.” This highlights the brand’s ability to deliver a nuanced flavor profile that appeals to sophisticated palates.
Read more about: Hollywood’s Casting Switch-Ups: Stars Who Were Fired From Big Movie Roles
Jeni’s also captures attention with its unique textural contributions. Nic Vanderbeeken, chef at Apéritif restaurant in Bali, singles out Jeni’s Brown Butter Almond Brittle for its “perfect balance between rich, nutty sweetness and the satisfying crunch of the brittle.” He adds that “The brown butter adds a depth that’s almost savory, which I find pairs beautifully with desserts that need a little extra complexity.” This showcases Jeni’s mastery in integrating textural elements to enhance, rather than merely accessorize, the overall flavor experience. Even Jackie Alpers, a chef and cookbook author, found Jeni’s Wildberry Lavender through a whimsical search for a blue ice cream, noting that despite its purple hue, it “tastes like summer and personifies the color lavender,” illustrating the brand’s evocative power.
Van Leeuwen, a New York-based brand, is another chef darling, particularly lauded for its commitment to high-quality, custard-based ice cream. Jonny McDermott of Pony Kitchen and Cocktails enthusiastically states, “It’s possibly the only brand that embraces the French tradition of custard-based ice cream making, very high quality and delicious. The honeycomb flavor is ludicrously good.” Seth Woods, chef at Metropolis Cafe and Aquitaine, finds Van Leeuwen’s Earl Grey Tea flavor “so fire and refreshing,” explaining that the tea is “actually steeped in milk to create the creamy tea flavor.” These endorsements underscore the chefs’ appreciation for traditional, meticulous preparation methods and inventive, yet balanced, flavor infusions.
Interestingly, many chefs gravitate towards brands and flavors that evoke a powerful sense of nostalgia, transporting them back to cherished moments. Rochelle Cooper, pastry chef in Washington, D.C., speaks fondly of Ben & Jerry’s Chunky Monkey, remembering how she “used to eat it and watch Nickelodeon as a kid growing up.” For her, it was an adventure “digging around for the big chocolate chunks.” Similarly, Tab Volpe, executive pastry chef in Boston, associates Friendly’s Jubilee Roll with “Christmas time in my household,” recalling its “chocolate chip ice cream base with a chocolate center and the fudge lines on top with candied almonds” as his favorite part.
These nostalgic picks are deeply personal. Volpe also cherishes Hood Rainbow Sherbet, a New England classic, stating that eating it “brings me back to my childhood summers.” Chef Nayibe Renaud, executive pastry chef at Komodo Las Vegas, unequivocally declares, “Baskin Robbins Cherry Jubilee will forever be my favorite nostalgic flavor and brand,” praising its “luscious blend of sweet cream, infused with vibrant cherry swirls” and “delicate notes of vanilla.” Chef Carl Dooley of Mooncusser and Moon Bar finds “New England nostalgia” in Friendly’s Orange Creme Roll Ice Cream & Sherbet Roll, calling it a “perfect mix of delicious creamsicles vibes” and a crowd-pleaser that makes “everyone’s face lights up, you feel like a kid.”
Product on Amazon: Van Leeuwen Premium Honeycomb French Ice Cream, 14 oz (Frozen)
Brand: Brand: Van Leeuwen
Price: 7.99 USD
Rating: 4.6 Total reviews: 1293
Features:
1. DELICIOUS FLAVOR – Despite being called honeycomb, it’s not made from any honey at all. It’s made with caramel candy. That all might seem confusing until you realize that ice cream is also made without ice. Your whole life has been a lie.
2. CLEAN LABEL – Our specialty ice cream Contains no high fructose corn syrup, artificial flavors, colors, or processed ingredients. Do what is right for your body and stick to the good ingredients.
3. HEALTHIER OPTION – Nowadays, people can spend so much time on what’s “healthy” They don’t stop to consider what’s healthy. As far as we’re concerned, happiness is healthiness, and Van leeuwen ice cream is the right choice for anybody.
4. GREAT TASTE – Van Leeuwen classic and Vegan ice creams are made with just a handful of fresh ingredients. Each flavor is a celebration of some of the world’s best Artisan producers and farmers both local and from around the world.
5. OUR STORY – We started Van Leeuwen Ice Cream in a yellow truck on the streets of NYC in 2008 with a mission to make good ice cream that makes you feel good. This is our way. The good way. The Van Leeuwen way. Not just the best way to make ice cream, but to live.
Shopping on Amazon >>
The power of ice cream to evoke memory stretches across cultures and continents. Aidan Mc Gee, chef at The Dubliner and McGonagle’s Pub, shares that a scoop of Kell’s Kreme mint chocolate chip “brings me back to the seaside in Ireland as a kid,” illustrating the universal ability of specific flavors to act as time machines. Adam Young, owner and chef of Sift Bake Shop in Connecticut, sums up the allure of heritage brands like Warwick Ice Cream, noting that “The classic technique and even packaging lends to nostalgia of year’s past,” making it a “summer tradition” with his daughters.
While big names have their place, many chefs also champion smaller, regional, or even fiercely local ice cream purveyors, recognizing their unique craft and charm. Bob Broskey, chef and partner at RPM Restaurants, goes so far as to order Chad’s Vanilla Ice Cream from Millie’s Homemade in Pittsburgh, calling it a “fantastic product from a husband and wife team.” He admits they “may or may not order a few pints a couple of times a year to Chicago,” showing a remarkable dedication to a superior product. Cody Pruitt, managing partner of Libertine in New York City, vouches for Adirondack Creamery Vanilla, which he calls “anything but plain.” He praises its purity: “It’s one of the rare ice creams that tastes of what it is (or what it should be): velvety dairy, aromatic vanilla bean, and a bit of sugar. It’s pure, it’s about as craveable as they come, and I don’t feel like I’m filling my body with various emulsifiers and stabilizers.”
Within the vibrant culinary scene of Greater Boston, local ice cream culture thrives, and chefs have no shortage of favorite spots. Joanne Chang, chef and co-owner of Flour Bakery + Cafe, “adores Cabot’s Ice Cream & Restaurant,” noting how it’s “always packed with families” and marveling at “all the kids demolishing their towering sundaes and frappes.” She praises the “super friendly and fast” service, concluding, “You can’t go wrong here. You will walk out with a huge smile,” with her personal go-to being cherry vanilla and peach frozen yogurt.
Product on Amazon: 365 by Whole Foods Market, Ice Cream Mint Chocolate Chip, 1.5 Quart
Brand: Brand: 365 by Whole Foods Market
Price: 5.99 USD
Rating: 4.6 Total reviews: 2654
Features:
1. Brought to you by Whole Foods Market. Our standards are what set us apart, and our quality is what keeps us stocking pantries, fridges and freezers with the best natural and organic 365 Everyday Value products every day.
2. Certified Gluten-Free.
3. Certified Kosher.
4. Certified Vegetarian.
Shopping on Amazon >>
Read more about: 17 Childhood Joys Men Loved As Kids But Now Avoid As Adults
Sam Treadway, bar director of Backbar, gives “local love to Gracie’s Ice Cream in Union Square,” specifically enjoying “one of their Oreo flavors in their famous Fluff cone.” Michael Pagliarini, chef and owner of Guilia and Moëca, also supports Gracie’s, highlighting its “perfect small business Union Square vibe” and calling the black raspberry chip “fantastic!” Treadway also loves Honeycomb Creamery in Cambridge, always opting for their signature “Salted Caramel Crackle because the texture of the Honeycomb candy bits is unreal.” These local gems are cherished for their unique atmosphere and singular offerings.
Rancatore’s Ice Cream and Yogurt also holds a special place, particularly for its Kulfi flavor. This traditional Indian version of ice cream, flavored with cardamom, saffron, and pistachio, evokes “very fond childhood memories of eating it on hot summer days in Delhi,” making it a rare and authentic find in the area. Toscanini’s, another Cambridge institution, is Matt Gaudet’s “go-to” from his days living there, praising the B3 (brown butter, brown sugar, and brownies) flavor as “awesome!” These local establishments often excel by offering distinct, culturally significant, or inventively crafted flavors that resonate deeply with chefs.
Even regional chains earn the culinary stamp of approval. Valerie Nin, Executive Pastry Chef for Boston’s Grill 23, an Ohio native, favors Graeter’s Black Raspberry Chip. She describes how “They stream liquid chocolate into their ice cream after it’s done churning and mix it in, so instead of chocolate chips you get irregular pieces of dark chocolate,” making each pint feel like “finding buried treasure.” This exemplifies the appreciation for unique techniques that lead to exceptional results. Christina Ferrari, pastry chef and owner of Shoreline Lake Boathouse & American Bistro, keeps coming back to Häagen-Dazs Rum Raisin, despite trying ice creams globally, calling it “a classic for a reason” and praising “the juxtaposition of flavors and textures” as “pure deliciousness.”
Product on Amazon: Oreo Frozen Sandwiches, 4 Ct
Brand: Visit the Oreo Store
Price: 6.29 USD
Rating: 4.6 Total reviews: 176
Features:
1. One 4-count box of OREO Frozen Dairy Dessert Sandwiches
2. Delicious creme-flavored frozen dairy dessert packed with real OREO cookie pieces and sandwiched between two LARGE OREO wafers
3. Each sandwich is an individually wrapped single-serving frozen treat that you and your family and friends can enjoy anytime
4. Enjoy this OREO frozen dairy dessert in a cone, sundae, or custom recipe
5. OREO, the OREO Wafer Design, and AMERICA’S FAVORITE COOKIE are trademarks of Mondelēz International group, used under license
Shopping on Amazon >>
In essence, the chefs’ collection of beloved ice creams is a testament to the fact that exceptional taste is multifaceted. It’s not just about brand recognition, but about genuine quality, thoughtful execution, and the ability of a frozen treat to evoke profound joy and personal history. From the consistent creaminess of a widely distributed pint to the whimsical crunch of a local artisan’s creation, their recommendations serve as a masterclass in appreciating the nuanced art of ice cream. They beckon us to explore beyond the familiar, to seek out not just a flavor, but an experience that delights the palate and nourishes the soul.
