Ever found yourself yelling at your TV, convinced you’ve stumbled upon the greatest show ever created, only for it to feel like no one else on the planet has even heard of it? You’re absolutely not alone in that feeling! In an age where hundreds of original shows drop every single year, it’s pretty much an impossible mission to watch everything. And let’s be real, that means some truly unsung masterpieces inevitably get sidelined while everyone else is busy obsessing over the latest *Game of Thrones* or *Breaking Bad*.
While hopping on the popular show bandwagon or re-watching your go-to comfort binge for the tenth time is super tempting, we’re here to tell you it’s seriously worth it to branch out! There are so many lesser-known shows out there just waiting to blow your mind. Seriously, you’ll thank us later. We’ve done the digging, chatted with a bunch of dedicated binge-watchers (and thrown in a few of our own faves, of course!), to unearth some of the most underrated television gems that you need to add to your queues.
So, the next time you’re stuck in that endless scroll on a streaming service, wondering what to dive into next, consider these under-appreciated hits. From heartwarming comedies to intense dramas, and even some genre-bending animated wonders, these shows are ready to become your next obsession. Get ready to fall hopelessly in love with stories and characters that will leave a permanent imprint on your heart.
1. Schitt’s Creek: From Riches to Rags, a Heartwarming Transformation
Okay, so *Schitt’s Creek* might sound a little… corny, maybe even a bit confusing at first glance, but trust us, you need to push past that title because this show is an absolute revelation. It kicks off with the super-wealthy Rose family losing every single penny they have, forcing them to ditch their lavish lifestyle and start fresh. Picture this: nearly all their material possessions are seized by authorities, with one hilarious exception—a town called Schitt’s Creek that they once bought as a joke. Yep, a joke purchase becomes their only refuge.
The series then follows Johnny (Eugene Levy), Moira (Catherine O’Hara), David (Daniel Levy), and Alexis (Annie Murphy) as they navigate their new reality. They’re stuck adapting to a poorly kept motel as their new home, and suddenly, they’re on this wild, unexpected journey of small-town living and incredible self-discovery. It’s truly like no other show on television, blending humor with genuine heart in a way that just sticks with you.
I was personally a bit reluctant to give it a try, but once I did, I fell hopelessly in love, and you will too. The show has started to get some much-deserved praise, especially during its fourth season, but honestly, the level of appreciation is still not high enough. The acting is superb, the storylines are a perfect blend of hilarious and deeply meaningful, and the characters? Oh, the characters! They are so brilliantly written and performed that they will absolutely leave permanent imprints on your heart.
What makes it so binge-able is how it makes you feel. You’ll genuinely laugh out loud, you’ll definitely tear up, and sometimes, you’ll do both simultaneously in the span of a single scene. After you finish the series (and you will, trust us), you’ll want to scream-recommend it to every single living being you encounter. To this day, it remains the most enjoyable television binge I’ve ever experienced, and I’m pretty sure it will be for you too!
2. Peaky Blinders: Dive into the Gritty, Stylish World of the Shelby Clan
If you’re hunting for a show that delivers thought-provoking drama, intense action, and character relationships that will absolutely hook you, then you can stop scrolling right now and look no further than *Peaky Blinders*. This British crime series is a masterclass in storytelling, focusing on the intricate inner workings of the Shelby clan in Birmingham, England, right after World War I. It’s dark, it’s stylish, and it’s utterly compelling.
Led by the incredibly fearless Tommy Shelby (portrayed with magnetic intensity by Cillian Murphy), the family members form the formidable Peaky Blinders—one of the area’s most powerful and ruthless gangs. Together, they embark on a mission to control the streets of Birmingham, putting outsiders in their places and going to truly great lengths to protect each other, no matter the cost. The show just oozes atmosphere, from the period setting to the killer soundtrack.
Seriously, *Peaky Blinders* is so good it’s honestly mind-boggling at times. While it’s already a massive hit in the UK, it’s high time the rest of the world caught on and experienced its sheer brilliance. Every single episode is packed with a constant stream of suspense and adrenaline, keeping you on the edge of your seat. Just when you think you’ve got the Shelby family all figured out, they pull a fast one over on you, keeping the twists and turns coming.
The writing is sharp, the performances are phenomenal, and the stakes always feel incredibly high. Plus, and this is a big one, the show has perhaps the most badass theme song of all time, which perfectly sets the tone for the gritty, dangerous world you’re about to enter. Prepare to be immersed in a world of power, family loyalty, and brutal ambition that will keep you hitting ‘next episode’ until the very end.
3. Lovesick: An Unconventional Rom-Com with Unexpected Depth
Before you even ask, yes, *Lovesick* was formerly titled *Scrotal Recall*. Yep, you read that right—*Scrotal Recall*! But let’s move past that unforgettable (and frankly, hilarious) original title, because this British sitcom is an absolute hidden gem. It centers around a protagonist named Dylan (played by Johnny Flynn) as he embarks on what has to be one of the most uncomfortably unique journeys in rom-com history: visiting all his past lovers to inform them he has a sexually transmitted disease. Fun, right?!
But don’t let the premise fool you into thinking it’s just a cringe-fest. *Lovesick* masterfully explores the electric sparks, the reassuringly magical comforts, and the often impossible awkwardness that come with intimate friendships, romantic relationships, and just, well, life in general. It bounces between past and present, showing us Dylan’s relationships as he reconnects with his exes, giving us glimpses into how he got to where he is now.
It’s a show that manages to be incredibly sweet, genuinely funny, and surprisingly insightful all at once. Our very own Mashable Entertainment Reporter Proma Khosla has even outlined seven compelling reasons why it’s such a perfect binge! These include its next-level ability to portray existential dread—which, let’s be honest, we can all relate to sometimes—along with some especially sweet and believable friendships that are the heart of the show. Plus, it boasts a refreshingly diverse cast, making it feel current and inclusive.
The humor is clever, the characters are wonderfully flawed and relatable, and the narrative structure keeps you engaged, peeling back layers of Dylan’s life with each episode. You’ll find yourself rooting for him, cringing with him, and absolutely falling in love with the ensemble cast. It’s a beautifully written and acted series that might just make you rethink what a romantic comedy can be. Give *Lovesick* a chance; it’s a feel-good (and feel-awkward) journey you won’t regret.
4. Great News: The Quirky Workplace Comedy You Totally Missed
If you’re a fan of smart, fast-paced workplace comedies with a unique twist, then *Great News* is about to become your new favorite show you didn’t know you needed! This delightful series follows Katie Wendelson (Briga Heelan), a truly dedicated producer at the cable news network MMN. While she’s constantly battling to prove to her colleagues that she’s got what it takes to excel in the super-competitive industry, life throws her a curveball.
Her incredibly overbearing mom, Carol (played by the phenomenal Andrea Martin), just happens to get hired as the company’s newest intern. Casual, right?! This hilarious mother/daughter duo then has to juggle to strike a delicate balance between their personal and professional lives, all while working alongside a truly unique and eccentric crew of news lovers. It’s chaotic, it’s heartwarming, and it’s absolutely side-splittingly funny.
As Proma, 27, perfectly put it, “*Great News* is a fabulous oddball workplace comedy that should’ve fit right into the NBC family but never quite found its audience.” She’s not wrong! It channels the absolute best *30 Rock* vibes—which makes total sense since it’s from the same producers and features *30 Rock* writer Tracey Wigfield. You’ll love its TV-insider setting and its insanely talented cast. Where else, Proma asks, “can you see Broadway legend Andrea Martin nail punchlines alongside Nicole Richie?”
Even though the series’ original run may have ended, the binge is definitely forever. You’ll find yourself laughing at the absurd situations, appreciating the clever writing, and falling for the quirky characters. It’s a show that delivers constant laughs and a surprising amount of heart, making it the perfect escape into a world of controlled chaos and undeniable charm. Don’t let this one slip through your fingers any longer; it’s *Great News* for your watchlist!
5. Younger: Age is Just a Number When You’re Reinventing Your Life
Prepare to fall head over heels for *Younger*, a show I personally love so damn much that I’ve already outlined a number of reasons why everyone else should give it a watch. This series creatively and brilliantly tackles ageism in the workplace, all centered around 40-year-old Liza Miller (the fantastic Sutton Foster). She concocts a plan to pass herself off as a 26-year-old in order to get back into the highly competitive publishing industry after a long break.
Starting over as an assistant at Empirical Publishing, Liza embarks on an exhilarating journey where she reclaims her youth, dives back into a dynamic career, and finds new friendships and romances. The catch, of course, is that she’s constantly struggling to hide her big secret from pretty much everyone: her uptight boss (Miriam Shor), her vibrant 20-something co-worker Kelsey (Hilary Duff), a charming young love interest named Josh (Nico Tortorella), and the sophisticated head of the publishing house, Charles (Peter Hermann). It’s quite the ride, full of close calls and hilarious near-misses!
Every episode of *Younger* is a refreshing delight, packed with just the right amount of drama, smart humor, a love for books, and incredibly close-knit relationships that feel genuinely earned. It’s the kind of show that makes you feel good without shying away from real-life complexities. If you’re searching for a feel-good comfort binge that also offers a surprising amount of depth, then this is absolutely the show for you. It’s got a compelling central premise that explores themes of identity, second chances, and the challenges women face in their careers and personal lives.
What makes *Younger* so irresistible is its ability to balance lighthearted fun with meaningful social commentary, all wrapped up in a super stylish package that’s easy on the eyes. The fashion is on point, the New York City setting is enchanting, and the cast has incredible chemistry that makes you invested in every character’s journey. You’ll find yourself cheering for Liza as she navigates her double life, falls in love, and builds a new future. It’s a smart, sassy, and utterly charming series that will hook you from the very first episode.
Beyond the Hype: Continuing our journey through the best-kept secrets of the small screen, this section uncovers five more incredible shows. We’ll explore their innovative concepts, unforgettable characters, and the reasons they’ve become cult favorites, ensuring your watchlist is never dull again.
6. Skin Wars: Fresh Paint: The Ultimate Artistic Reality Binge You Never Knew You Needed
Alright, prepare yourselves for a reality show experience that’s as captivating as it is visually stunning! *Skin Wars: Fresh Paint* dives headfirst into the incredible world of body art, transforming human canvases into living masterpieces. This series, part of the larger *Skin Wars* franchise, takes a fresh approach by pitting a group of talented artists against each other in a series of intense challenges, all under the watchful eyes of former *Skin Wars* contestants who act as their mentors. It’s a fascinating look at the creative process, where the human form becomes the ultimate medium for breathtaking art.
The competition is fierce, the stakes are high, and the creativity is absolutely off the charts. Each episode pushes these artists to their limits, demanding innovation, precision, and a whole lot of artistic flair. From intricate designs that play with light and shadow to bold, fantastical creations that completely transform the model’s identity, you’ll be constantly amazed at what these artists can achieve. Our very own Ali, 23, perfectly described it as “Netflix’s *Nailed It*, but with less baking and more nudity,” capturing the fun, slightly chaotic, and utterly delightful vibe of the series.
But wait, there’s more! The show is hosted by none other than the iconic RuPaul Charles, who brings his signature charisma, wit, and wisdom to every episode. Imagine six artists, some taking their very “first brush strokes as competitive body painters,” being guided and judged by the queen herself. It’s a masterclass in creativity and entertainment, unfolding over a tight and incredibly satisfying nine-episode run. Seriously, if you’re looking for something truly unique, visually spectacular, and genuinely engaging, you cannot recommend “this 9-episode masterpiece enough.” And remember Ali’s pro tip: you might want to “Enjoy without pants” for the full immersive experience. You’ll be amazed by the artistry!
7. Forged in Fire: Where Bladed Battles and Fiery Feats Take Center Stage
Ready for a show that’s equal parts mesmerizing and, let’s be honest, a little bit terrifying? *Forged in Fire*, straight from The History Channel, is *not* your average competition series. It throws a group of amateur knife-makers into an arena where they must combine raw materials, incredible creativity, and masterful skill to craft game-changing blades that are put to the ultimate test. Hosted by Wil Willis, an expert on weapons and a veteran of the U.S. Army and Air Force, this show ratchets up the intensity to eleven in every single episode.
The premise is deceptively simple: craftsmen are challenged to forge various types of weaponry, from historical swords to modern tactical knives, using ancient techniques and modern tools. But the journey from raw steel to a finished, functional blade is anything but. You’ll witness the grueling process of hammering, heating, shaping, and sharpening, often under immense time pressure. Our pal Bob, 29, hits the nail on the head, calling it a “truly dumb and troubling show” – and honestly, that’s part of its undeniable charm, especially with those glorious slow-motion shots of “fire, sparks, and red-hot metal being pounded by industrial hammers.”
But here’s where *Forged in Fire* truly separates itself from the pack: the testing phase. Forget gentle critiques; these blades are built for function, and they are tested with brutal efficiency. Bob perfectly summarized it as “essentially *Chopped* but with weapons,” and he’s not wrong! At the end of each episode, the enormous swords and custom knives are put through rigorous durability and sharpness tests, often on ballistic gel torsos, to see “if they are capable of killing a man.” This show is an absolute adrenaline rush, a captivating blend of history, craftsmanship, and pure, unadulterated danger.
8. Don’t Trust the B in Apartment 23: Your Next Favorite Hilarious Roommate Ride
Who *isn’t* in the mood for a show about roommates? We thought so! Get ready to dive into the brilliantly chaotic world of *Don’t Trust the B in Apartment 23*. Even though this gem “abruptly ended after two seasons,” it promises to fill your life with an abundance of joy, laughter, and perhaps a healthy dose of lovable mayhem. This is the story of June (played by the fantastic Dreama Walker) and Chloe (the utterly captivating Krysten Ritter), two personalities so wildly different, they’re practically from different planets, as they navigate the rocky terrain of working, making friends, and, most importantly, living together in New York City.
June arrives in the city with big dreams and an earnest, slightly naive outlook, only to find her life quickly upended. Enter Chloe, her cynical, manipulative, yet undeniably charming and free-spirited roommate, who sees no problem with taking advantage of June at every turn. Their dynamic is the beating heart of the show, a constant push and pull between June’s desire for normalcy and Chloe’s unapologetic embracing of chaos. You’ll watch as June tries to adjust to Chloe’s outrageous pranks and schemes, often with hilarious and unexpected consequences.
And if that wasn’t enough to hook you, this upbeat comedy series provides “constant laughs” from start to finish. But here’s the glorious cherry on top: James Van Der Beek stars as himself, in a truly self-deprecating and utterly brilliant portrayal of a washed-up actor clinging to his past fame. His interactions with Chloe, who considers him her best friend, are pure comedic gold, elevating the show from a simple sitcom to something truly special and self-aware.
Our very own Mashable Entertainment Reporter Alison Foreman was so enamored with this show that she “outlined a solid 23 reasons why you should give the show a chance,” which, if that doesn’t scream ‘must-watch,’ we don’t know what does! She promised that “the comedic beats of *Don’t Trust the B* sizzle with sparkling finesse,” and that you “will laugh until your face hurts.” Seriously, the writing is clever, the performances phenomenal, and the energy infectious. If you’re ready for some serious belly laughs and a delightfully unconventional take on the roommate comedy, this is your next binge-watching assignment!
9. The Mindy Project: A Rom-Com Lover’s Dream, Unapologetically Herself
Get ready to fall head over heels for Dr. Mindy Lahiri in *The Mindy Project*, where the brilliant Mindy Kaling truly shines, both on-screen and behind the scenes. This show is an absolute must-see, chronicling the chaotic, hilarious, and deeply relatable journey of a young OB-GYN who’s constantly striving to improve her personal life, excel in her demanding career, and find that elusive true love – all while remaining “unapologetically herself.” It’s a refreshing take on the romantic comedy genre, infused with a vibrant, modern sensibility.
Mindy Lahiri is the kind of protagonist you instantly root for: flawed, ambitious, a little bit messy, and utterly endearing. You’ll join her as she navigates the often-awkward world of dating, deals with workplace politics, and grapples with the everyday challenges of being a professional woman in New York City. Her personal quest for happiness and romance is often hilariously disastrous, but always delivered with a self-awareness and optimism that makes her journey incredibly engaging.
Mindy Kaling’s writing is truly “beyond hilarious,” packing the show with “brilliant one-liners you’ll be thinking about months later.” But *The Mindy Project* isn’t just about the laughs; it also fearlessly tackles important topics like “sexism, racism, fertility, and single-parenthood with humor and tact.” This show doesn’t shy away from real-world issues, instead weaving them into the narrative in a way that feels authentic and thought-provoking, while never losing its comedic touch. Plus, the show is “full of a quirky bunch of charismatic and lovable supporting characters” who “come to feel more like family members” by the end.
For any fan of Mindy Kaling, great comedy, sharp writing, or memorable pilots, *The Mindy Project* is a non-negotiable watch. It’s a show that “gives romantic comedies the love they deserve,” celebrating the genre while also subverting its tropes. You get to see her “reunite with *The Office* co-star B.J. Novak” and, in an absolutely historic episode, “Mindy Lahiri is a White Man,” watch her brilliantly “call out privileged white men around the world.” Seriously, if you miss out on this show, you’ll be missing out on a truly delightful, insightful, and laugh-out-loud funny experience that redefines what a modern rom-com can be.
10. Peep Show: The Bleakest Comedy That Lets You Inside Every Thought
Ever wondered what’s really going on inside someone’s head? *Peep Show* offers exactly that, and it’s a game-changer. This British narrative comedy series isn’t just about the chaotic lives of roommates Mark (played by David Mitchell) and Jeremy (Robert Webb) as they stumble through life in search of love; it’s told from a truly unique first-person perspective, allowing viewers to “essentially hear their every thought.” This ingenious narrative device creates an unparalleled intimacy, making you feel like you’re not just watching the show, but literally living inside their often-hilarious, often-cringeworthy minds.
Mark, the perpetually anxious, socially awkward historian, and Jeremy, the lazy, self-absorbed musician, are two sides of the same dysfunctional coin. Their misadventures range from failed romantic encounters to disastrous career attempts, all viewed through their unfiltered internal monologues. It’s a brilliant portrayal of the internal anxieties and petty judgments that we all experience but rarely voice. Adding to the star power, none other than Olivia Colman is in it, bringing her incredible talent to this darkly comedic world long before she became the global sensation she is today.
Our friend Corey, 33, perfectly captured the essence of why this show is such a cult classic, boldly stating that *Peep Show* “is one of the bleakest comedies out there — is there higher praise to be had?” And he’s absolutely right! While Mark and Jeremy repeatedly manage to “ruin weddings, relationships, childhoods, and most everything else,” the show somehow manages to make you incredibly fond of them. The sheer honesty of their inner thoughts creates a bond with them “in a way that feels different and deeper than most sitcoms,” transforming mere observation into profound (and profoundly funny) empathy.
*Peep Show* masterfully “lets you laugh without having to ignore the pitch-black abyss at the core of modern life.” It’s a comedy that doesn’t shy away from the darker, more uncomfortable truths about human nature, but instead finds humor in them. If you’re looking for a show that’s genuinely smart, laugh-out-loud funny, and offers a refreshingly honest (and often painful) look at two very flawed individuals just trying to get by, then prepare to have your mind, and your funny bone, thoroughly blown. It’s an essential watch for anyone who appreciates humor with a side of existential dread.
And there you have it, folks! From the breathtaking artistry of body painting to the intense crafting of blades, from hilariously dysfunctional roommates to the deeply personal journey of an OB-GYN, and the unfiltered thoughts of two British slackers, these shows prove that some of the greatest television experiences are often found off the beaten path. So, next time you’re scrolling endlessly, feeling like you’ve seen it all, remember these incredible series. They’re waiting to become your next obsession, ready to captivate your imagination, make you laugh until your sides hurt, and remind you why branching out your watchlist is always, always a good idea. Happy bingeing!
