Okay, pizza lovers, gather ’round! We all know that feeling: it’s been a long day, you’re starving, and the thought of cooking anything elaborate sends shivers down your spine. That’s where the glorious, always-there-for-you frozen pizza comes in. It’s the ultimate comfort food, a quick dinner solution, and a canvas for your culinary creativity – even if that just means opening a box and sliding it into the oven. But with the frozen pizza market being a colossal $18.8 billion business, the freezer aisle can feel less like a wonderland and more like an overwhelming labyrinth of crusts, toppings, and sauces.
Seriously, how do you even begin to choose? From thin crusts that snap to thick, doughy rising crusts, and every topping combination imaginable, it’s a lot. We’ve all been there, staring blankly at the rows of boxes, wondering if we’re about to commit to a delicious dinner or a regrettable disc of disappointment. The good news? We’ve bravely navigated the icy depths of the grocery store freezer section, sampling a whole bunch of brands, from iconic classics to gourmet imports, so you don’t have to endure any more “meh” pizza nights.
So, buckle up, because we’re about to unveil the truly awesome frozen pies that are absolutely worth grabbing. Whether you’re a purist, a pepperoni fanatic, a veggie lover, or on the hunt for something uniquely gourmet, we’ve got the lowdown on which pizzas will transform your dinner emergencies into genuinely satisfying feasts. Get ready to find your next go-to frozen pizza that will make you shout, “It’s not delivery, it’s *delicious*!”
1. **Motor City Pizza Co. Detroit-Style Double Pepperoni**Alright, let’s kick things off with a true champion that’s making waves far beyond the Motor City itself. Motor City Pizza Co. specializes in the absolutely revolutionary Detroit-style pizza, a pie defined by its thick yet crispy crust, typically shaped into a rectangle or square. If you’ve never experienced the magic of Detroit-style, prepare for a revelation: it’s a whole different ball game, and this brand has absolutely nailed it in the frozen aisle.
Shoppers consistently rave about Motor City Pizza Co. Double Pepperoni, often declaring it superior to most pizza places and even anything you could whip up at home. One Redditor perfectly summed up its appeal, praising the “immaculate” texture. Imagine sinking your teeth into a pizza “loaded with caramelized cheese edges, pillowy crust, and crispy pepperoni” – seriously, it’s a textural dream come true that balances indulgence with perfect crunch.
What truly sets this pie apart is its dedication to that classic Detroit experience. You get not one, but “two styles of crispy pepperoni,” ensuring every bite is packed with that savory, slightly spicy kick we all crave. And let’s not forget the crust, which has been hailed as the “best garlic bread-meets-pizza-crust I’ve ever tasted.” It’s a bold claim, but one that countless fans back up with gusto, proving that frozen can indeed be fabulous.
This gem isn’t just a Costco exclusive; while you can grab a convenient two-pack there, it’s also available at other major retailers like Walmart or Target. This means you don’t need a membership card to get your hands on what one shopper boldly claimed is “the best frozen pizza I’ve ever had.” Another fan added, “I love them. Not only do they taste great but they always cook the same each time,” speaking to the consistent quality that makes this a freezer essential.
Read more about: After Rigorous Testing: Frozen Pizzas Put to the Test – Discover Which Ones Truly Deliver
2. **Screamin’ Sicilian Bessie’s Revenge Cheese Pizza**If a pizza could scream its deliciousness from the freezer aisle, it would definitely be Screamin’ Sicilian. This brand isn’t shy, and its packaging often features a hollering Sicilian, Papa Palermo, an Italian immigrant who started his authentic pizza business in Wisconsin. Their Bessie’s Revenge Cheese Pizza is a testament to this legacy, offering “bold flavors, thick-cut mozzarella, and a pizzeria-style crust” that demands attention.
This isn’t your average cheese pizza; Screamin’ Sicilian takes things to another level. They proudly state that their original cheese pizza uses “ridiculous amounts of shredded mozzarella and white cheddar cheese atop our stone-fired butter pizza crust and secret-recipe tomato sauce.” And just when you think you’ve reached peak cheese, “it’s topped with MO slices of freshly cut Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.” Yes, that’s “cheese on top of cheese, now that’s a cheese pizza!”
It’s no wonder that shoppers consistently maintain this is “the most indulgent and delicious cheese pizza in the freezer section.” Reviewers agree, noting it as “one of the better pizzas we tasted.” The robust, tangy tomato sauce combined with a “multitude of cheeses including parmesan, Romano, cheddar, and two kinds of mozzarella” creates a flavor profile that’s rich and satisfying, crowned with generous slabs of fresh mozzarella.
While it might come with a slightly “higher price” compared to some budget options, the consensus is that for the quality and generous toppings, “it better be!” and it delivers. This pizza isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience, bringing that authentic, over-the-top pizzeria indulgence right into your home. If you’re looking for a cheese pizza that truly lives up to its name and then some, Bessie’s Revenge is ready to conquer your cravings.
3. **PORTA Brick Oven Uncured Pepperoni Pizza**Ever dream of being whisked away to a quaint little pizzeria in Italy without leaving your kitchen? PORTA Brick Oven Uncured Pepperoni Pizza promises just that, and from what we’ve seen, it absolutely delivers. Found at Whole Foods, this line of pizzas is a true passion project, crafted by Italian chef Cosimo Mammoliti who meticulously sources ingredients directly from Italy. We’re talking about tomatoes from Campania, flour from a fourth-generation mill in Le Marche, and even 100% Coratina extra-virgin olive oil.
This dedication to authentic, high-quality ingredients shines through in every bite, creating a frozen pizza experience that feels genuinely gourmet. Shoppers have celebrated this commitment, with one Redditor exclaiming, “Quality from the freezer aisle!” It’s not just the backstory that impresses; it’s the tangible difference these premium components make to the overall taste and texture of the pie.
The crust, in particular, has garnered immense praise. One shopper emphatically declared it the “Best crust I found on a frozen pizza by far,” a critical factor for any true pizza aficionado. This isn’t a flimsy, afterthought of a crust; it’s a foundational element that elevates the entire pizza, showcasing the skill and heritage behind its creation. The brick oven method undoubtedly contributes to its superior texture and flavor.
And when it comes to flavor, this pepperoni pizza does not disappoint. Another enthusiast gushed, “Porta is the best frozen pizza I’ve had. The spicy pepperoni one is superb!” The uncured pepperoni brings a clean, savory punch, perfectly complemented by the rich tomato sauce and the outstanding crust. If you’re seeking a frozen pizza that offers a taste of true Italian craftsmanship and high-brow ingredients, PORTA is your one-way ticket to a delicious, authentic experience.
4. **Kirkland Signature Supreme Cauliflower Crust Pizza**For those navigating the world of gluten-free eating, or simply looking for a fantastic, veggie-packed pizza option, the Kirkland Signature Supreme Cauliflower Crust Pizza from Costco is an absolute game-changer. Forget everything you thought you knew about cauliflower crusts, because this one stands head and shoulders above the rest. It’s so good, in fact, that it’s been touted as “better than any cauliflower crust I’ve had at a pizzeria.”
Finding a truly exceptional gluten-free pizza, whether from a pizza shop or the grocery store’s freezer aisle, can feel like a quest. But according to the enthusiastic masses on Reddit, there’s only one answer when it comes to the best Costco products: “This is ridiculous. It’s obviously the frozen cauliflower crust pizza. Real Kirkland G’s know,” one shopper passionately stated. This isn’t just good for a gluten-free option; it’s just plain *good* pizza.
What makes it so stellar? The crust, while it “may not fool a connoisseur,” is “fairly crispy” and doesn’t leave you missing the chewy gluten of traditional dough. But the real magic lies in the toppings: it’s “topped with the best meats and veggies as an added perk,” ensuring a flavorful and satisfying experience. The “tender and flavorful” vegetables don’t waterlog the crust, maintaining that delightful crispness.
Coupled with “quality pepperoni, sausage, and an epic three-cheese blend,” this pizza delivers a robust flavor profile that can easily compete with—and even surpass—many gluten-rich options out there. If you’re looking to cut carbs, adhere to a gluten-free diet, or just want a surprisingly delicious and wholesome frozen pizza, the Kirkland Signature Supreme Cauliflower Crust Pizza is a supreme choice that you absolutely need in your freezer.
Read more about: After Rigorous Testing: Frozen Pizzas Put to the Test – Discover Which Ones Truly Deliver
5. **Amy’s 4 Cheese Pizza**Amy’s Kitchen has long been a trusted name in the health-conscious frozen food sphere, extending its mission of organic and vegetarian options far beyond just pizza. While their entire line is commendable, the Amy’s 4 Cheese Pizza is a standout, offering a delightful twist on the classic Quattro Formaggi that consistently wins over discerning palates. It’s a testament to how simple, quality ingredients can truly shine.
This particular version boasts a harmonious blend of “fontina, provolone, Parmesan, and mozzarella layered over our pizza sauce made with organic tomatoes on a hand-stretched crust of organic wheat flour.” It’s this careful selection and thoughtful layering that creates a pizza bursting with “Really great flavor.” The organic tomato sauce, in particular, receives glowing reviews, with one Redditor exclaiming, “The tomato sauce on those is absolutely incredible.”
The crust, described as “hand-stretched organic wheat flour,” provides a satisfying base that holds up beautifully to the generous toppings. While some reviewers noted it needed a bit longer in the oven to achieve optimal crispness, the effort is well worth it for the resulting texture. The interplay of the four cheeses melts into a rich, gooey perfection that complements the vibrant sauce.
Despite its “small size” and a price point that some might consider “a little pricey,” many shoppers find its quality and generous flavor make it “two or three meals so it’s worth it.” It’s a solid choice that exemplifies the brand’s commitment to wholesome, delicious food. If you’re looking for a robust and flavorful cheese pizza with organic bona fides, Amy’s 4 Cheese Pizza is a delightful and worthwhile indulgence for any pizza night.
6. **California Pizza Kitchen BBQ Chicken Pizza**When you hear “BBQ Chicken Pizza,” one name instantly springs to mind: California Pizza Kitchen. This brand is basically the “legendary version” of this iconic pie, and thankfully, their frozen rendition brings all those beloved restaurant flavors right into your kitchen. It’s a phenomenal way to enjoy a classic without having to leave the house, consistently hitting “all the sweet, smoky, and cheesy notes perfectly.”
Fans are absolutely ecstatic about this frozen take on a restaurant classic. One shopper enthusiastically declared it “My all time favorite! 10/10,” while another chimed in with, “I love this one. It’s probably my favorite CPK pizza. I have nothing but good things to say about it.” This level of devotion speaks volumes, highlighting how successfully CPK has translated its signature dish into a convenient, at-home format.
The balance of flavors is truly its forte. The tangy BBQ sauce, the tender chicken, the vibrant red onions, and the generous blanket of gooey mozzarella cheese all come together in a symphony of taste that’s both familiar and incredibly satisfying. It’s that perfect blend of savory, sweet, and smoky that makes this pizza so addictive and a go-to for many who crave something a little different from traditional pepperoni or plain cheese.
While California Pizza Kitchen is renowned as a full-blown restaurant, their foray into the grocery store freezer aisle has proven to be a resounding success, much like other popular chains. If you’re already a fan of their dining experience, you can expect to be equally thrilled with their frozen pizza offerings. For a reliable, flavorful, and genuinely satisfying BBQ Chicken Pizza experience, CPK remains the gold standard in the frozen food section.
Read more about: Ever Wonder What A-List Stars Really Eat? These 15 Master Chefs Are Bringing the Heat (Right Into Their Homes!)
7. **Trader Joe’s Roasted Garlic & Pesto Pizza with Deep Fried Crust**For those who march to the beat of a different drum—or rather, a different sauce—Trader Joe’s Roasted Garlic & Pesto Pizza with Deep Fried Crust is an absolute revelation. If you’re not a fan of traditional red sauce, or simply crave a flavor profile that’s wonderfully unique, this pie is ready to win you over “with flying flavors.” It’s a bold departure from the norm that delivers on its promise of an exciting culinary journey.
The star of the show here is undoubtedly that “crispy, golden crust” combined with an intensely “garlicky pesto sauce.” This duo works in perfect harmony, creating a taste experience that reviewers describe as bringing “restaurant-level quality to your kitchen.” Forget bland or predictable; this pizza is vibrant and sophisticated, offering a delightful alternative to the usual suspects in the frozen aisle.
The “Deep Fried Crust” is a particularly intriguing element, offering a texture that’s distinct and incredibly satisfying. It’s this attention to detail in the crust that elevates the entire pizza, ensuring every bite is a textural pleasure. The rich, aromatic pesto, infused with roasted garlic, provides a savory depth that lingers pleasantly, making it a memorable meal.
Indeed, this version of “fried pizza” will instantly transport you to the bustling “streets of Naples, Italy,” evoking a sense of authentic, gourmet street food. It’s a fantastic option for anyone looking to shake up their pizza routine, providing a gourmet flair without the gourmet price tag or the need for a plane ticket. If a vibrant pesto and a uniquely delicious crust sound like your kind of party, this Trader Joe’s specialty is a must-try.
Now that we’ve savored some of the absolute titans of the frozen pizza world, it’s time to venture deeper into the freezer aisle. Our journey continues, exploring even more must-try frozen pizzas that promise to satisfy every craving, from timeless classics to unique flavor adventures and wallet-friendly options. Get ready to uncover which pies deliver big on taste and value, ensuring your freezer is stocked with nothing but the best for your next pizza emergency or spontaneous movie night.
8. **Good & Gather Self-Rising Crust Uncured Pepperoni Frozen Pizza**Who doesn’t love a pizza that actually *rises*? Target’s Good & Gather Self-Rising Crust Uncured Pepperoni Frozen Pizza totally delivers on that promise, giving you a wonderfully browned and puffy crust that’s both satisfying and inviting. It’s a comforting classic that genuinely comes through with that self-rising magic, making it a solid contender in the pepperoni pizza lineup.
When it comes to flavor, this pizza offers a sauce that’s pleasantly “tomatoey, sweet, and slightly garlicky,” forming a delightful base. However, if you’re a pepperoni purist, you might find the slices a bit “sparse,” “distributed unevenly,” and on the “oily” side, with “grease dripping off each one.” But don’t let that deter you entirely; there’s a definite star here that makes up for it!
What truly sets this pie apart, and why it’s absolutely worth grabbing, is its incredible cheese. Described as “chewy, stringy, and plentiful,” it literally “covered the pizza crust to crust.” If you’re the type of person who always asks for extra cheese on your delivery order, then this Good & Gather gem is practically made for you, ensuring every bite is loaded with gooey, savory goodness.
9. **Newman’s Own Uncured Pepperoni Pizza**If you’re into a thinner, crispier crust but still want quality ingredients, Newman’s Own Uncured Pepperoni Pizza could be your new go-to. It offers a “Tombstone-esque, cracker-y crust,” but with a significant upgrade thanks to its “higher-quality ingredients,” including “whole wheat and whole-milk mozzarella.” It’s designed to provide a “light, dynamic texture” that’s a step above many other thin-crust options.
The commitment to quality really shines through with the cheese, as Newman’s Own proudly uses “100% whole-milk mozzarella.” While some tasters praised its flavor, others amusingly “remarked it tasted like string cheese,” proving that taste is indeed subjective! However, there was a general consensus among reviewers that the pizza could definitely use “more of it” to truly achieve cheesy perfection.
Beyond the crust and cheese, this pie brings a distinct flavor profile that some found “too salty, with an overpowering dried-herb taste.” So, if you’re sensitive to those bolder seasonings, you’ll want to keep that in mind. Overall, it’s a strong contender for those seeking a more refined thin-crust pepperoni experience, bridging the gap between convenience and a touch of gourmet.
10. **Tombstone Original Thin Crust 5 Cheese Pizza**Sometimes, you just want to kick it old school, and that’s where the Tombstone Original Thin Crust 5 Cheese Pizza swoops in to save the day! If you’re craving that quintessential “throwback, kid-friendly pizza” vibe but want to skip the pepperoni, this pie totally delivers. It’s perfect for those moments when you just want a taste of nostalgia without any fuss.
This pizza keeps things refreshingly simple and familiar. The sauce is a “basic marinara with a nice acidic kick,” which pairs perfectly with the “chewy cheese” that lovingly “reminded tasters of cafeteria lunch.” It’s all about embracing those comforting, no-frills flavors that take you right back to your childhood, making dinner easy and fun.
And let’s talk about that crust! It’s delightfully “crunchy around the edges and bready toward the center,” giving you a satisfying texture with every bite. While this pizza “won’t blow anyone away” with avant-garde flavors, it’s a reliable, inexpensive, and genuinely fun option that will absolutely “take you back in time” for a truly classic frozen pizza experience.
11. **Amy’s Margherita Pizza**For those who appreciate wholesome ingredients and a more handcrafted feel, Amy’s Margherita Pizza offers a delightful “homemade vibe” that stands out in the freezer aisle. It’s a fantastic choice for anyone seeking a simpler, cleaner pizza experience, especially if you’ve already enjoyed Amy’s other vegetarian and organic offerings like their 4 Cheese pizza.
The crust is a star here, featuring a “whole-wheat crust” that “tastes nutty and has a satisfying chew,” reminiscent of “a good homemade crust.” This thoughtful base supports a vibrant “sauce [that] is bright and fresh, with chunks of tomato,” bringing a burst of garden-fresh flavor that’s truly commendable for a frozen pie.
Toppings include “cubes of fresh mozzarella,” which tasters found “very mild,” contributing to the overall gentle profile. You’ll also spot “green flecks of basil,” which, despite their presence, offer “only a mild herb flavor.” This creates a comforting and clean taste that is deeply appreciated by those who typically find other frozen pizzas “too processed.” The “noticeable taste of olive oil” further enhances its authentic, wholesome appeal.
While some reviewers noted its “small size” and a price that’s “quite small for the price,” many still find its quality and robust flavors make it a worthwhile indulgence. It exemplifies Amy’s commitment to delicious, organic food, making it a perfect pick for a satisfying and genuinely good meal that feels like it came straight from your kitchen.
12. **Trader Joe’s Pizza Margherita**Trader Joe’s is known for its unique and often beloved takes on everyday foods, and their Pizza Margherita is no exception. This pie brings some serious “pizza oven realness” to your kitchen, making it an intriguing option for crust aficionados who enjoyed their pesto offering but are looking for a more traditional, red-sauce experience. Prepare for a crust that aims for greatness!
Indeed, the highlight here is undoubtedly the “chewy, slightly charred, adequately seasoned crust,” which delightfully “reminded our tasters of slice-joint pizza.” This is a foundational element that truly elevates the entire experience. The sauce, while “bright and delivers on tomato flavor,” does “lean sweet and goes a bit overboard on the oregano,” giving it a distinctive character that some will love and others might find a little bold.
However, it’s worth noting that the “margherita” label might be a bit of a stretch when it comes to the cheese. Topped with “deli-counter-style slices of mozzarella, rather than fresh mozz,” it’s probably “really just a cheese pizza” in disguise. This might be a bit “underwhelming” for those expecting true margherita authenticity, but don’t let that deter you entirely.
Ultimately, despite the cheese not quite living up to the “margherita” name, the Trader Joe’s Pizza Margherita is still a very “serviceable cheese pizza at a reasonable price,” largely thanks to that fantastic crust. If you’re looking for a budget-friendly option with a surprisingly good crust, this one from your favorite quirky grocery store is definitely worth a try.
Read more about: Trader Joe’s Defies Retail Norms: Why Human Connection, Not Self-Checkout, Is Speeding Up Your Shopping Experience
13. **DiGiorno Original Rising Crust Four Cheese Pizza**Alright, let’s talk about a legend! No discussion of frozen pizza is complete without a nod to DiGiorno, a brand so iconic that most Millennials can probably recite its tagline by nostalgic memory: “It’s not delivery. It’s DiGiorno.” This “veritable legend in the frozen pizza category” features the signature “pillowy dough, sweet tomato sauce, and loads of gooey cheese” that has defined countless quick dinner fixes.
DiGiorno is synonymous with its “Rising Crust” — a style that promises a thick, doughy base that expands wonderfully in the oven. However, this signature can sometimes lead to a bit of a dilemma, with tasters finding “there’s too much crust” and it can be a “super doughy pizza,” potentially “eclipsing the many ingredients on top.” While it’s all about that doughy embrace for some, it might be a bit much for others.
Still, for those moments when you need a “quick pizza fix,” DiGiorno absolutely gets the job done. It’d do “great” for a fast, satisfying meal, but as reviewers note, “it won’t leave a major lasting flavor impression” and is “best eaten hot out of the oven.” It’s a reliable, comforting, and undeniably nostalgic choice that continues to hold its place as a freezer aisle staple.
14. **Red Baron Brick Oven Crust Pepperoni Pizza**Stepping into the ring as another “famed frozen pizza brand” is Red Baron, instantly recognizable with its jaunty aviator mascot. This brand has been slinging pizzas since 1976, and many of us probably have a “guilty fondness” for its various offerings, much like the convenience of their French bread singles. It’s a true classic that consistently delivers.
We tested their brick oven crust pepperoni pizza, which features pepperoni made from a “blend of pork, chicken, and beef.” This pie is thoughtfully “topped evenly with cheese and pepperoni,” and what truly stands out is the “subtle kick of spice” that reviewers enjoyed. After encountering some overly sweet sauces, this gentle heat was a refreshing change of pace.
Furthermore, the crust on this Red Baron offering really holds its own. It “took on a great texture” and boasted a “nice balance of salt,” making it a satisfying foundation for the toppings. Overall, while this pizza isn’t necessarily “breaking the mold” or reinventing the wheel, it’s certainly “good enough for casual enjoyment.” Combined with its “affordable price point,” it’s a “fine option for shoppers who aren’t looking for anything fancy” and just want a solid, dependable pepperoni pizza.
Read more about: After Rigorous Testing: Frozen Pizzas Put to the Test – Discover Which Ones Truly Deliver
So there you have it, fellow pizza adventurers! Our deep dive into the wondrous world of grocery store frozen pizzas proves that you don’t need to break the bank or wait for delivery to enjoy a truly stellar slice. From crispy thin crusts to thick, doughy delights, and from classic comforts to unique flavor explosions, the freezer aisle is bursting with options that are genuinely worth your hard-earned cash and precious freezer space. Whether you’re a purist, a pepperoni fiend, a veggie enthusiast, or someone always on the hunt for a gourmet twist, there’s a frozen pizza out there waiting to become your next obsession. So go forth, explore, and may your pizza nights always be delicious and gloriously hassle-free!
