Thrift shopping has always been a necessity for many. In recent years it has become a treasure hunt for the frugal and the fashion-forward alike. Searching through the shelves, racks and piles in a thrift store is like diving into a sea of forgotten stories, each item whispering tales from the past. The trend in thrift shopping is growing because of stories of vintage gems and valuable finds for pennies on the dollar.
No longer is the thrift store shopper born of necessity it has become a browser’s paradise for the pursuit of vintage gems and budget-friendly finds. Thrifting as the experienced call has evolved into a chic trend, celebrated by fashionistas and eco-conscious shoppers. The past four years of hyper-inflation have also opened the world of thrifting to those that have never experienced it. As the spotlight on thrifting grows and its social media footprint becomes more pervasive, a pressing question lurks in the shadows: Are thrift stores becoming too expensive?
The original customers of thrift stores who have been searching their aisles for years say the answer is a resounding YES. Less than a decade ago thrift stores were the go-to places for bargain hunters looking for deals that surpassed even the least expensive big box stores. In fact, higher prices at the big box stores pushed a segment of their shoppers down the retail ladder to find bargains at thrift stores.
A stroll through the aisles at a thrift store today is telling a different story. Prices are up, and thrift stores are stocking overstocked or obsolete items donated by traditional retailers. These are not damaged or broken items but the latest items in their original packaging. As more people turn to thrifting as an essential shopping experience in search of affordable products thrift store execs have taken notice of the surge in demand and taken their shopping experience up a notch. Stores are neater, with a footprint that mimics major retailers.
Those with a pulse on shopping discovered they could have a side hustle on eBay and Depop if they could source a supply of products. While shopping for themselves to save money over the box stores and the rise in prices at Amazon discovered that thrifting is a source of products that they could flip through their own stores on eBay, Depop and now a host of other selling platforms that could be turned into a lucrative side hustle.
The pendulum swung again when thrift store executives noted the surge in sales they wondered why and did some market research. Not only did they begin to raise prices, but they also established their own departments to cull through donations to sell online before shoppers even saw them. The value of donated goods from estates and an aging population were now carefully assessed and kept off the sales floors. The thrift stores were now competing with a segment of their own customer base, the thrift store shoppers who were shopping for bargains that they could turn over for a profit were being shut out.
In the eye of the storm and getting the evil eye from once loyal customers is Goodwill. Originally seen by most as a non-profit pillar of the community with a mission to provide job training and employment services to people with disabilities and other barriers to employment, Goodwill quickly became the competition.
The rising prices at Goodwill stores and a large department dedicated to pulling the best out of the donations and selling them online at retail and beyond left supporters feeling a sense of betrayal. The thrift store shoppers noticed first, but soon those who were apt to donate were questioning whether the organization was straying from its noble path and becoming another corporate behemoth.
Goodwill moved to clarify its stance and operational model. The organization emphasizes that its stores serve a dual purpose: To provide affordable options to shoppers and to fund its various programs, including youth and veteran programs, recycling initiatives, and rehabilitation programs. However, these concerted reassurances did not address the exorbitant executive salaries that are beyond many other not-for-profit organizations.
Goodwill claims that 92 cents of every dollar spent in their stores and generated by online sales goes directly towards supporting its mission. The problem is in the numbers, does the. 92 cents include store overheads and executive salaries? There is a delicate balance that Goodwill strives to maintain. Keeping prices low enough for shoppers while generating enough revenue to support its charitable endeavors is reasonable enough.
Every dollar spent at Goodwill contributes to empowering individuals facing economic barriers, the question is does this justify the higher prices? It invites dialogue, encouraging us to weigh a desire for bargains against the social good achieved through purchases.
In the evolving retail landscape, thrift is claiming a stake. Prices are rising, but they are still below the big box stores that destroyed American Main Streets. Older shoppers still hold that grudge, but younger ones born and bred in the social media digital age not so much. They have a new target creating knots in their conscious, it is the controversy surrounding thrift stores, especially Goodwill. Their complaint centers on their pricing and the perceived drift from their core mission. As thrift store prices rise, the concern is that these organizations are realigning as retailers who pose as not-for-profit organizations. It used to be that they were not-for-profit organizations using retail to sustain their mission.
Although other nationally well-known organizations that use the thrift store model to support their mission, Goodwill, has become the center of the discussion. The Goodwill mission is simply stated as, “a nonprofit organization with a mission to enhance the dignity and quality of life of individuals and families by strengthening communities, eliminating barriers to opportunity, and helping people in need reach their full potential through learning and the power of work.” As their retail footprint has grown there is a perception that they have shifted their focus. Many see Goodwill as a for profit corporation masquerading as a community do-gooder.
As the big box stores undergo another reincarnation to lower prices, will thrift stores respond In kind? Can thrift stores maintain their appeal as a community asset while growing profits exponentially? As they lose shoppers because of the rise in prices and filter out the real bargains that used to make it to the floor Goodwill is eroding shopper trust. Once the hallmark of the operation, donations from individuals have now shifted to donations from corporations for tax write-offs. It is the reason that Goodwill stores feature a significant percentage of newly packaged retail items.
The core Goodwill shopper has less of a choice of used clothes and treasures which was the hallmark of their thrift store shopping experience. It remains to be seen if the thrift industry will collapse under its own weight as corporate retailers.
Related posts:
Goodwill responds to increased prices
